Re:We need to stop pretending AI is intelligent
by hwpythonner on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @01:27PM
(#43708058)
The whole “AI doesn’t understand” argument assumes we do.
John Searle’s Chinese Room makes the case: a person follows rules to manipulate Chinese symbols without knowing the language. From the outside, it looks like understanding—but inside, it’s just symbol shuffling.
But what if that’s us too?
What if our brains are just predictive engines—layers of heuristics, compression, and feedback—outputting the next “token” based on statistical patterns?
What if intelligence is just what statistical fluency feels like from the inside?
John Searle’s Chinese Room makes the case: a person follows rules to manipulate Chinese symbols without knowing the language. From the outside, it looks like understanding—but inside, it’s just symbol shuffling.
But what if that’s us too?
What if our brains are just predictive engines—layers of heuristics, compression, and feedback—outputting the next “token” based on statistical patterns?
What if intelligence is just what statistical fluency feels like from the inside?