http://example.com/article/story?storyID=19039&ref=329932&sessionID=9043275
http://example.com/article/story?storyID=19039&ref=902932&sessionID=9023409
http://example.com/article/story?storyID=19039&ref=904354&sessionID=8230235
... infinite ...
Canonical URL meta tags can help.Filtering out certain query parameters (JSESSIONID, PHPSESSIONID, etc) can help.
Sitemaps help.
I'm rather impressed that search engines do it so well. I imagine the right approach involves examining the contents of the pages and doing checksums, but I'd love to know what the real search engines do.
I do know that a naive crawler will completely fail to crawl any significant portion of the real web without solving this. It's quite possible those 250 million "pages" were actually something like 1 million distinct pages.
Interesting point. Q: Is it possible for two different pages to give the same checksum? (Asking for my own info; I do know what checksums are, in overview, from way back, but haven't checked :) them out much.
Also it doesn't help you at all because pages returned that you want to treat as the same aren't actually the same because they include the request time or other unique element.
Edit: Added sentence about comparing with domains.
A very simple and reliable web crawler can be built by building something that takes a list of in-urls, fetches the pages, parses them, and emits a list of out-urls.
The out-urls from that phase become the in-urls of the next phase.
If you do this you'll find the size of the generation get larger for a while, but eventually it starts getting smaller and if you take a look at it you'll find that almost everything getting crawled is junk -- like online calendars that keep going forward into the future forever.
At some point you stop crawling, maybe between generation 8 and 12, and you've dodged the web trap bullet without even trying.
This classifier can be trained using logistic regression.
This is slightly tricky, but effective. I've been meaning to write in more depth about this topic (smart crawling).
[edit: I'm stepping out so I can't write more right now. You can email me if you have any questions about this.]
Something I didn't deal with at all was spider traps. My thinking there was that this was a relatively shallow crawl, so the dangers of getting badly stuck weren't too great. For deeper crawls this would be essential.
Then you have a giant heap with several billion elements that you're going to be updating 100s of entries on each webpage you crawl. I'm pretty sure that'll be your new bottleneck.
Besides, it still doesn't solve the problem of content farms and spam.
>set a max pages to crawl per site to prevent never ending single site crawls?
You either set the limit too low and don't crawl, for example, all of wikipedia, or you set the limit too high and still waste tons of resources.
It's probably best to add an IP based limit factor too to handle link farms.
Something like "max-pages crawled is directly proportional to the (incoming links / linking unique domains)"; or just have it naively proportional to the linking unique domains to reduce processing cost.
There are span sites with more incoming links than Wikipedia....
Designing crawl policy is a lot like designing security policy. The opposition is very well-funded, smart, experienced, and very motivated.
If you're just smart, they've got you beat.
Google apparently solve this with a domain trust factor discounting link juice from low value domains for SERPs purposes but I'm not sure what they feed forward to control their bots.
This means that for some time it has appeared that large numbers of low quality inbound links has been a negative for Google SERP placement ... so I'm wondering if such [spam] domain owners are being as smart as you think??
It's been several years since I worked on Yahoo's crawler.
It's interesting that at the beginning of this, you doubted that spam domains could have large number of inbound links (and suggested that inbound link counts was a powerful indicator) but by the end, you seemed aware of such domains....
I'm not. I've never done any research on "spam domains". Do you have any examples or not?
Then who wrote
> This means that for some time it has appeared that large numbers of low quality inbound links has been a negative for Google SERP placement
?
But none of that presupposes any knowledge of "spam sites", nor of the particular instances you note of spam sites with lots of inbound links (ie the claimed far more than wikipedia [per IP address]).
But it seems you don't have any examples so I'm not sure why you're persisting. Even if I did know about specific spam sites with lots of incoming links I don't see the relevance of my knowing that to you answering the question of if you can give any examples of sites with your claimed characteristics. The points are orthogonal. Your pre-knowledge of such sites is not in any way bound by my knowledge of such sites.
I daren't ask if you can answer the question again. But just suppose you could then a response would still be of interest.
After crawling your list of seed URLs, where do you go next? How do you make sure you don't crawl the same content multiple times because it has a slightly different URL? How to avoid getting stuck on unimportant spam sites with autogenerated content?
Because the author only crawled domains from a limited set and only for a short time, he did not need to care about that part. Nonetheless, it's a great article that shows many of the pitfalls of writing a webcrawler.