News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Surgeons in England to adopt checklists - expect to halve... by omouse on Friday January 16, 2009 @11:24AM (#436791)
I'm going to be as nice and polite as I can be here.

Medical science has had a long history, at least a few hundred years and performs studies/experiments/etc. to make sure that things work.

Witch doctors try random shit and see what sticks to the wall even if it means the patient dies.

Do you see the difference?

If doctors were killing a lot of people, I'm sure journalists would have jumped all over it by now and a lot of doctors would have malpractice suits filed against them.

Antibiotics do work. There have been studies to prove that. This isn't the small-time, this isn't the minor leagues, these pharma-companies are paying a big chunk of change to make sure something useful happens when you take those pills.

If you want lies and deceit, I suggest you go to a "natural" "organic" pharmacy that sells homeopathic garbage.

Re:Surgeons in England to adopt checklists - expect to halve... by RK on Friday January 16, 2009 @03:32PM (#437219)
these pharma-companies are paying a big chunk of change to make sure something useful happens when you take those pills.

Unfortunately, it's not always clear that those drugs do work. The problem isn't in the scientific process, but how it's often carried out and reported by the companies, who know exactly what it takes to get FDA approval (this is BIG business). I'm interested in how this process can be improved.

The "alternative/complementary" medicine thing is a red herring, to be polite.

Here's an interesting article that discusses some of the less than ideal ways that pharmacy companies report the science behind the drugs they develop, among other things.

http://www.nybooks.com/articles/22237

I think it's an important and interesting issue that needs to be addressed better (probably by the government).

Re:Surgeons in England to adopt checklists - expect to halve... by omouse on Friday January 16, 2009 @06:13PM (#437445)
You are correct of course. I remember reading about some pill right after WW2 that caused many birth defects but was approved for the public. It is a big business which is precisely why there needs to be an overseeing body.

Alternative medicines isn't a red herring, it relates directly to witch doctors. None of these alternative medicines are tested properly in an objective matter to prove that they do in fact work. These people still haven't gotten to step 1 on the stairs of science, while pharma companies are at step 123901823091283 though still need to climb a few more.

Re:Surgeons in England to adopt checklists - expect to halve... by RK on Friday January 16, 2009 @11:20PM (#437739)
I meant a red herring in the sense that alternative medicine is not really an alternative to actual medicine.
Re:Surgeons in England to adopt checklists - expect to halve... by Alex3917 on Friday January 16, 2009 @09:11PM (#437650)
"None of these alternative medicines are tested properly in an objective matter to prove that they do in fact work."

Many have been tested and proven to work. The only reason they are "alternative" is that doctors only prescribe medicines that the pharma companies promote. So they will prescribe people statins to lower their cholesterol, but they would never advise someone to take red rice even though it does the exact same thing with less risk of complications.

Re:Surgeons in England to adopt checklists - expect to halve... by maximilian on Friday January 16, 2009 @10:34PM (#437704)
"Many have been tested and proven to work."

Are they in the journals though? (i'm asking honestly, i'd be very interested to know)

Re:Surgeons in England to adopt checklists - expect to halve... by Alex3917 on Friday January 16, 2009 @11:26PM (#437746)
Yes, but I'm not an ND or MD so I don't know which journals are reputable and which are not. I get the feeling that research on botanical medicine mostly gets published in the same journals that publish normal pharmaceutical research, it's just that doctors only prescribe things that come in pill form.
Re:Surgeons in England to adopt checklists - expect to halve... by Alex3917 on Friday January 16, 2009 @11:54AM (#436844)
"Medical science has had a long history, at least a few hundred years and performs studies/experiments/etc. to make sure that things work."

And when push comes to shove, there's a simple procedure that can cut your risk of dying from surgery in half, and it's illegal for your doctor to use it in the US. As in if they do, they lose their medical license and go to jail. Why? It's insane.

"One of the sad realities of ignoring history is that almost every American is ignorant of the fact that medical freedom was tragically left out of the American Constitution. In 1776, Dr. Benjamin Rush, Surgeon General and the only American doctor to sign the Declaration of Independence, tried strenuously, but failed, to have "medical freedom" enshrined in the Constitution. He stated "The constitution of this Republic should make special provisions for Medical Freedom. To restrict the art of healing to one class of men and deny equal privileges to others will constitute the Bastille of medical science. All such laws are un-American and despotic."

If this amendment were actually enacted then probably your risk of dying in surgery would be 50% of what it actually is today.

Re:Surgeons in England to adopt checklists - expect to halve... by ahoyhere on Friday January 16, 2009 @06:29PM (#437465)
There is a problem, in that a medical doctor will often prescribe you expensive irritable bowel syndrome drugs when eating live culture yogurt or swallowing some culture pills (from those "natural" "organic" pharmacies) will solve the problem faster and cheaper.

The "natural" stuff is about half real and half hokum.

Unfortunately, it seems like regular medicine is, too.

Re:Surgeons in England to adopt checklists - expect to halve... by maximilian on Friday January 16, 2009 @10:31PM (#437701)
This is where the problem is. How does one properly filter the real from the fake? I find myself quite annoyed with the whole thing. (especially homeopathy)