On the other hand, I have yet to have to implement a liveness probe with an Elixir app, and I've had to do that with .NET because it can and does freeze. That game server also didn't use up all the available cores as well as the Elixir app. We also couldn't attach a REPL directly to the .NET app, though we certainly tried.
I would be curious to see if Rust works out better in production.
Sigh. I swear, the affliction of failing to understand the underlying concepts upon which a technology A or B is built is a plague upon our industry. Instead, everything clearly must fit into the concepts limited to whatever “mother tongue” language a particular developer has mastered.
Ironic, since any time you post about a programming language it's to inform that C# does it better.
Not just here; someone with your nick also whined when the creator of C# made a technical deficient decision when choosing Go over C# to implement typescript.
It's hard for a rational person to believe that someone would make the argument that the creator of the language must have made a mistake just because he reached for (in his words) a more appropriate language in that context.
You have a blind spot when it comes to C#. You also probably already know it.
You know you could have just linked the reply instead? It states "C#, F# or Rust". But that wouldn't sound that nice, would it? I use and enjoy multiple programming languages and it helps me in day-to-day tasks greatly. It does not prevent me from seeing how .NET has flaws, but holistically it is way less bad than most other options on the market, including Erlang, Go, C or what have you.
> It's hard for a rational person to believe that someone would make the argument that the creator of the language must have made a mistake just because he reached for (in his words) a more appropriate language in that context.
So appeal to authority trumps observable consequences, technical limitations and arguments made about lackluster technical vision at microsoft? Interesting. No, I think it is the kind of people who refuse to engage with the subject on their own merits that are a problem, relegating to the powers that be all the argumentation. Even in a team environment, sure it is easier to say "a team/person X makes a choice Y" but you could also, if the situation warrants it, expand on why you think this way, and if you can't maybe you shouldn't be making a statement?
So no, "TypeScript, including Anders Hejlsberg, choosing Go as the language to port TS compiler to" does not suddenly make pigs fly, if anything, but being seen as an endorsement from key C# figure is certainly a bad look.
Your argument is that you have a better grasp of "technical limitations" than Anders Hejlsberg?
You'll forgive the rest of us for not buying that; he has proven his chops, you haven't, especially as the argument (quite a thorough explanation of the context) from the typescript team is a lot more convincing than anything we've seen from you (a few nebulous phrases about technical superiority).
> but being seen as an endorsement from key C# figure is certainly a bad look.
Yeah, well, the team made their decision with no regard to optics. That lends more weight to their decision, not less.
Typescript is a huge success from Microsoft in terms of recapturing developers, without them knowing. MS is not a charity, look at how little love they give to F# compared to TS.
* My personal guess is that the age old MS instinct came into play: be coûte que coûte backwards compatible, port all the bugs, do not disturb anything.
* A second reason might be that TS people might not want to learn .net because of vibes. Do not underestimate vibes. Almost everyday on HN I see Python programs being posted where most often the creator would be better of if they had learned some next programming language. Decisions are seldomly made on a technical basis. We as humans decide emotionally, sometimes with rationalizations afterwards. And so, maybe Anders was rational in acknowledging the dev-social situation as is.
Whatever the reason, this will not be without consequences. The team now has to invest in GO and now depends on Google to take TS forward. And yes, this is also typical MS, one department can easily undo the other.
TLDR: the technical arguments were mostly nonsense, but the real arguments have likely more to do with age-old reflexes and dev-cultural issues.
Well that’s great. I didn’t mention Rust in that list because it does seem to perform well. Its async is also known as to be much more difficult to program.
> and having much lower memory footprint. You cannot compare Erlang/Elixir with top of the line compiled languages.
And yet I do and have. Despite all the cool tech for C# and .Net, I’ve seen simple C# web apps struggle to even run on Raspberry pi’s for IoT projects while Elixir ones run very well.
Also note Elixir is a compiled language and BEAM has JIT nowadays too.
I did hesitate to add C# to that list because it is an impressive language and can perform well. I also know the least about its async.
Nothing you said really counters that async as a general paradigm is more likely to lead to worse performance. It’s still more difficult to profile and tune than other techniques even with M:N schedulers. Look at the sibling post talking about resource allocation.
Even for Rust there was a HM post recently where they got a Rust service to run a fair bit faster than their initial Golang implementation. After months of extra work that is. They mentioned that Golang’s programming model made it much easier to write fairly performant networking code for. Since Go doesn’t use async it seems reasonable to assume go routines are easier to profile and track than async even if I lack knowledge of Go’s implementation details on the matter. Now I am assuming their Rust implementation used async but don’t know for sure.
Let's see it perform faster than Python first :)
Also, if the target is supported, .NET is going to unconditionally perform faster than Elixir. This is trivially provable.
> Nothing you said really counters that async as a general paradigm is more likely to lead to worse performance. It’s still more difficult to profile and tune than other techniques even with M:N schedulers. Look at the sibling post talking about resource allocation.
Can you provide any reference to support this claim as far as actually good implementations go? Because so far it looks like vibe-based reasoning with zero knowledge to substantiate the opinion presented as fact.
That's not surprising however - Erlang and Elixir as languages tend to leave their heavy users with big knowledge and understanding gaps and their communities are rather dogmatic about BEAM being the best next thing since sliced bread. Lack of critical thinking leads to such a sorry place.
Ah yes now to the No True Scotsman fallacy. Async only works well when it’s “properly implemented” which is only .NET.
Even some .NET folks prefer actors model for concurrent programming:
> Orleans is the most underrated technology out there. Not only does it power many Azure products and services, it is also the design basis for Microsoft Service Fabric actors, which also power many Azure products. Virtual actors are the perfect solution for today’s distributed systems.
> In my experience Orleans was able to handle insane write load (our storage/persistence provider went to a queue instead of direct, it was eventually consistent) so we were able to process millions of requests without breaking a sweat. Perhaps others would want more durability, we opted for this as the data was also in a time series database before Orleans saw it.
https://www.reddit.com/r/dotnet/comments/16kk2l1/comment/k0x...
https://learn.microsoft.com/en-us/dotnet/orleans/benefits
Ironically what got me into Elixir was learning about Orleans and how successful it was in scaling XBox services.
> Because so far it looks like vibe-based reasoning with zero knowledge to substantiate the opinion presented as fact.
Aside from personal experience and years of writing and deploying performance sensitive IoT apps?
Well quick googling shows quite a few posts detailing async issues:
> What tools and techniques might be suited for this kind of analysis? I took a quick glance at a flamegraph but it seems like I would need a relatively deep understanding of the async runtime internals since most of what I see looks like implementation details.
https://www.reddit.com/r/rust/comments/uph4tf/profiling_with...
> Reading a 1GB file in 100-byte chunks leads to at least 10,000,000 IOs through three async call layers. The problem becomes catastrophic since these functions are essentially language-level abstractions of callbacks, lacking optimizations that come with their async nature. However, we can manually implement optimizations to alleviate this issue.
https://www.ajanibilby.com/blog/async-js-performance-apr23/
> Asynchronous Rust seems to perform worst than multi-threaded Rust implementations.
https://dev.to/deepu105/concurrency-in-modern-programming-la...
> Under realistic conditions (see below) asynchronous web frameworks are slightly worse throughput (requests/second) and much worse latency variance.
https://calpaterson.com/async-python-is-not-faster.html
> I’m not going to say all async frameworks are definitely slower than threads. What I can say confidently is that asyncio isn’t faster, and it’s more efficient only for huge numbers of mostly idle connections. And only for that.
https://emptysqua.re/blog/why-should-async-get-all-the-love/
https://users.rust-lang.org/t/my-benchmark-done-elixir-is-fa...
https://blog.blackfire.io/the-challenges-of-async-python-obs...
Also picking asyncio from Python. Lol. You can't be serious, can you?
The only impression I get is most Elixir/Erlang practicioners simply have ossified cluelesness and deep biases that prevent them from evaluating implementation/design choices fairly and reaching balanced conclusions on where their capabilities lie. Very far cry from the link salad you posted that does not answer my question e.g. the issues with .NET and Rust async implementations performance-wise.
It's impossible to have a conversation with someone deeply committed to their bias and unwilling to accept that BEAM is not the shining paragon of concurrent and multi-threaded runtimes it once was.
How can you make performance claims while getting the details completely wrong?
Neither .NET's nor Rust's Tokio async implementations work this way. They use all available cores (unless overridden) and implement work-stealing threadpool. .NET in addition uses hill-climbing and cooperative blocking detection mechanism to quickly adapt to workloads and ensure optimal throughput. All that while spending 0.1x CPU on computation when compared to BEAM, and having much lower memory footprint. You cannot compare Erlang/Elixir with top of the line compiled languages.