Re:Bonobos use a kind of syntax once thought to be unique to...
by cpa on Friday April 11, 2025 @01:46PM
(#43656447)
I’d love for that to be true, but our species dates back 300,000 years, while writing started only 3,000 years ago.
Writing is definitely not a fundamental trait of our species, although once we got this update, things started moving quickly.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Bonobos use a kind of syntax once thought to be unique to...
by mattdeboard on Friday April 11, 2025 @02:20PM
(#43656774)
The oldest known cave paintings are 50,000+ years old. Those count as archived information :) It's pictographic information but it _is_ stored information :) About a hunt or a ceremony or a disaster or ...
Re:Bonobos use a kind of syntax once thought to be unique to...
by jimkleiber on Friday April 11, 2025 @02:22PM
(#43656792)
What about oral histories? Why does it need to be written if it can be memorized and shared verbally?
Re:Bonobos use a kind of syntax once thought to be unique to...
by mattdeboard on Friday April 11, 2025 @02:27PM
(#43656855)
I think it's very possible there are other species that use "oral history" to convey information to their children, like whales, dolphins, etc., so it's not "safe" -- again just IMO -- to consider it uniquely human.
Re:Bonobos use a kind of syntax once thought to be unique to...
by bee_rider on Friday April 11, 2025 @02:45PM
(#43657053)
I guess it is hard to say… if you looked at humans in any random moment when we’ve been around, I suppose we’d look a lot like dolphins (not making much increments progress generation-to-generation).
But, it does feel like there’s something in our storytelling tendency, maybe just a quantitative difference (we do it a little bit more and some up with slightly better summaries) that creates a qualitative one (positive feedback loop in our ability to reason about the universe).
From that point of view, writing is just an iteration of the loop. A big one, though.
Re:Bonobos use a kind of syntax once thought to be unique to...
by barbazoo on Friday April 11, 2025 @02:08PM
(#43656666)
More like 5000 or 6000 years ago at least for permanent writing I'd say? I definitely read about cuneiform tablets and cylinders from 3500BCE.
Before that might have been on wood so we don't know much about it.