News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Atari Missile Command Game Built Using AI Gemini 2.5 Pro by miohtama on Friday April 11, 2025 @11:27AM (#43654937)
But when art is getting democratised, it is stealing, like we learnt from Ghiblification incident lask week.
Re:Atari Missile Command Game Built Using AI Gemini 2.5 Pro by krapp on Friday April 11, 2025 @11:29AM (#43654980)
AI isn't democratizing art. Art has always been democratized. If you want to draw something in the Ghibli style, go ahead, no one is stopping you. I saw plenty of great Ghibli style non-AI art on my timeline in response to that, some by people who just spent a few days teaching themselves. The means have never been more accessible.

But using AI to generate something in that style doesn't make you an artist. It isn't art, it's just a product.

Re:Atari Missile Command Game Built Using AI Gemini 2.5 Pro by sgtgig on Friday April 11, 2025 @11:59AM (#43655325)
Pretty much my exact sentiments. The Internet for a long time has contained more than enough information and connections to other people for anyone to learn nearly any skill they want. Anyone who wants to put in the work has the opportunity.

Celebrating the 'democratization' of these skills is just showing adversity to basic learning and thinking. I'm not gonna celebrate a billion dollar corp trying to replace fundamentals of being human.

Re:Atari Missile Command Game Built Using AI Gemini 2.5 Pro by Workaccount2 on Friday April 11, 2025 @12:14PM (#43655488)
>Celebrating the 'democratization' of these skills is just showing adversity to basic learning and thinking.

The reality is that you cannot become an expert in everything. I have songs I'd love to compose in my head, but it would be totally impractical for me to go through the hundreds/thousands of hours of training that would be needed to realize these songs in reality. Nor am I particularly motivated to pay someone else to sit there for hours trying to compose what I am telling them.

This is true for hundreds of activities. Things I want to do, but cannot devote the time to learn the intermediate steps to get there.

Re:Atari Missile Command Game Built Using AI Gemini 2.5 Pro by gazebo64 on Friday April 11, 2025 @01:42PM (#43656415)
>I have songs I'd love to compose in my head, but it would be totally impractical for me to go through the hundreds/thousands of hours of training that would be needed to realize these songs in reality. Nor am I particularly motivated to pay someone else to sit there for hours trying to compose what I am telling them.

So the alternative is that you'll pay a tech company instead -- to use their model trained on unlicensed and uncredited human works to generate a mishmash of plagiarized songs, the end result of which nobody will ever want to listen to?

Re:Atari Missile Command Game Built Using AI Gemini 2.5 Pro by sgtgig on Friday April 11, 2025 @01:48PM (#43656474)
> you cannot become an expert in everything

You don't have to though. Anyone who's spent a decent amount of time in a creative hobby will tell you they sucked when they started but they enjoyed the process of learning and exploring. I think you're depriving yourself of the mental benefits of learning a new skill and being creative. It flexes your mind in new ways.

If you just want something to exist, sure, but when you can press buttons and have a magic box spit out whatever you want with no effort, how much are you actually going to value it?

Re:Atari Missile Command Game Built Using AI Gemini 2.5 Pro by Workaccount2 on Friday April 11, 2025 @02:26PM (#43656846)
If you only knew how many hobbies I have already lol
Re:Atari Missile Command Game Built Using AI Gemini 2.5 Pro by SecretDreams on Friday April 11, 2025 @11:43AM (#43655145)
> But using AI to generate something in that style doesn't make you an artist. It isn't art, it's just a product.

This is probably how people felt at the advent of calculators

Re:Atari Missile Command Game Built Using AI Gemini 2.5 Pro by rowanseymour on Friday April 11, 2025 @12:10PM (#43655443)
Calculators, abacuses etc are tools that let you do math easier than in your head. People have done original math on all sorts of things.

Generative AI forces us to reconsider what original means because it's producing a "remix" of what it has seen before with no credit going to those who created those original works.

Re:Atari Missile Command Game Built Using AI Gemini 2.5 Pro by krapp on Friday April 11, 2025 @11:56AM (#43655292)
Equating the process of creating art with adding numbers together is a very HN answer. Unsurprising that so few people here see value in human expression, when their only concern is efficiently generating a minimum viable product as quickly as possible.

But... using a calculator doesn't make you a mathematician either. And one could argue that society has born real negative consequences from the inability of most people to do even basic math because of the ubiquity of calculators. There is a big difference between using a tool and having the tool do everything.

Do you really believe that society will benefit when most people don't know how to express themselves creatively in any way other than asking the magic box to make a pretty thing for them?

Re:Atari Missile Command Game Built Using AI Gemini 2.5 Pro by Vvector on Friday April 11, 2025 @04:45PM (#43658344)
It's not stealing when the original still exists. And art style is not copyrightable.

Our current laws are made to handle AI