That’s what makes the rest of your post — and especially your comment history — so fluxomely paradoxical: clarity on one hand, derailment on the other.
You start off by unjustly accusing us of not being rational, neurotically accusing us of suppressing you in bold black un-downvoted text, then abruptly pivot to strongly endorsing "Contaminated and Natural Lead Environments of Man" — a paper that genuinely deserves more public attention. So why bother first tumbling down the same slippery slope of self-pitying paranoia, selective skepticism, and gratuitous goalpost-shifting that has earned you a negative karma and well documented pattern of rebuttals you never address? That’s not curiosity — that’s performance. And it shortchanges everyone on HN reading in good faith.
https://news.ycombinator.com/threads?id=FalseNutrition
You clearly recognize credible science when you see it, as your support for "Contaminated and Natural Lead Environments of Man" shows. But paradoxically you lead with your pattern of paranoid rhetorical cheap shots, ignoring corrections, and doubling down on shaky claims. That pattern doesn't just erode your argument — it derails the conversation. HN deserves better.
Your instincts are right when it comes to the science, but your posting history tells a different story. Over and over, you’ve parachuted into threads with confidently wrong claims, ignored direct corrections, and doubled down with vague appeals to "common sense" instead of evidence. You raise objections that have already been addressed — not just by commenters, but by the actual data — and when shown to be wrong, you either ghost or pivot.
This isn’t about disagreement. This is about a pattern: skepticism as performance. A posture. The goalposts always move, the sources are always “dubious,” and somehow the real experts — the ones who've dedicated entire careers to this — are always just missing something obvious that only you can see. The fact that the people currently running this country do that so often because it's their brand, doesn't give you license to. Your persecution complex is not vindicated simply because Trump is critically endangering public health by appointing professional conspiracy theorist, anti-vaxxer Robert F. Kennedy Jr. as health secretary and head of the Department of Health and Human Services.
You’re emulating the exact pattern that’s made RFK Jr. one of the most destructive figures in public health, a man who’s spent his career poisoning trust in medicine and science while cashing in on the same conspiratorial legacy that has made JFK folklore into a market, cherry-picking science when it flatters his instincts, discarding it when it challenges them, and spinning conspiracy from the gaps. That’s not skepticism. It’s sabotage. And it kills people.
Your and RFK Jr.'s performative playing the victim and baseless conspiracy theories cause real-world damage, and you're culpable for the harm your words cause:
RFK Jr.’s Conspiracy Theories: Here’s What Trump’s Pick For Health Secretary Has Promoted:
https://www.forbes.com/sites/saradorn/2024/11/15/rfk-jrs-con...
Claim: Vaccines cause autism due to thimerosal. Fact: Multiple large studies show no link. Thimerosal was removed and autism rates still rose. Harm: Fueled anti-vaccine panic, increased disease outbreaks.
Claim: COVID vaccines were part of a plot; ivermectin was suppressed. Fact: Vaccines work, ivermectin doesn’t. Claims are baseless. Harm: Undermined trust in science, cost lives.
Claim: COVID was engineered to target ethnic groups. Fact: No evidence. Pure pseudoscience. Harm: Reinforces racist and antisemitic tropes.
Claim: 5G and Wi-Fi cause cancer and control behavior. Fact: Non-ionizing radiation does not damage DNA. Harm: Distracts from real health risks, spreads paranoia.
Claim: HIV may not cause AIDS. Fact: HIV causes AIDS. Proven beyond doubt. Harm: AIDS denial has killed millions.
Claim: Fluoride causes cancer, IQ loss, and disease. Fact: Fluoride is safe and reduces tooth decay. Harm: Undermines public health and clean water programs.
Claim: Mass shootings are caused by antidepressants. Fact: No causal link has been shown. Harm: Stigmatizes mental health treatment, shifts blame from guns.
Claim: The FDA suppresses unpatentable cures. Fact: FDA evaluates safety and effectiveness. Harm: Promotes snake oil over science.
Claim: The CIA killed JFK. Fact: No credible evidence; Oswald acted alone. Harm: Fuels distrust in government without proof.
Claim: Sirhan Sirhan was hypnotized to kill RFK. Fact: Sirhan admitted guilt and was convicted with evidence. Harm: Deflects responsibility, erodes justice system trust.
This isn’t healthy skepticism. It’s misinformation that spreads confusion, undermines institutions, and gets people hurt.
You invoke science when it flatters your instincts — like posting that excellent lead exposure paper — but abandon it the moment it challenges them. That’s not intellectual curiosity. That’s rhetorical cosplay. You’re not hunting truth — you’re hunting affirmation.
So let me offer a counter-example. Not a theory. Not a feeling. Not a vibe. Just the kind of real-world, measurable work that good science actually does.
I’ve spent decades building and supporting the software infrastructure behind public health tools developed by the Block family — UC Berkeley professors emeritus Gladys and Clifford Block and their son Torin Block — including the Block Food Frequency Questionnaire (FFQ) analysis system and the Alive! personalized intervention program, which educates, motivates, and measurably improves nutrition, physical activity, and diabetes prevention behaviors.
These are not abstract thought experiments. They’re rigorously validated interventions used in research studies, hospitals, clinics, and federal programs to evaluate diet, improve behavior, and reduce risk factors for chronic disease. Alive! is a computer-tailored email-based lifestyle intervention that’s been tested in randomized controlled trials and shown to significantly increase physical activity and improve diet — even among people starting from poor baseline habits.
This wasn’t just theory. NIH, CDC, and Kaiser Permanente funded this work — and in doing so, they paid my and the Blocks’ modest salaries for decades. They believed in the value of preventive health tools that could reach underserved populations and actually work. That public investment enabled the quiet infrastructure of health equity: software, research, behavior change, all rigorously validated and scaled with care.
Kaiser is one of the most respected health care providers in the U.S. — a stark contrast to the for-profit behemoths that have made a killing (literally) off denying care. You might have noticed what happened to the CEO of one of those companies: gunned down in the street and instantly lionized online as a folk villain finally facing consequences. That’s not justice, but it is a measure of the pain people feel after decades of systemic cruelty for profit.
Now imagine what happens when the agencies that actually try to prevent suffering — NIH, CDC, FDA — are systematically defunded, discredited, or taken over by conspiracy theorists like RFK Jr., whose job in the Trump administration is explicitly to dismantle those safeguards. You don’t just lose data or funding. You lose lives.
That’s what real evidence looks like: measurable outcomes in diverse populations, reproducible results, peer review, and follow-up. Not vibes. Not self-pitying claims of censorship. Not pretending that you're the only rational one in the room while repeating conspiracy theories about fluoride, antidepressants, and the CIA.
I’ve worked with NutritionQuest for decades because they’re relentlessly focused on tools that work — quietly, rigorously, and at scale. I help keep the systems running: secure, adaptable, and solid under pressure. No hype. No posturing. Just outcomes.
So yes, let’s absolutely question power. Let’s hold institutions accountable. But let’s also recognize when something actually works — and hold ourselves to the same standard we demand from everyone else.
Otherwise, we’re just chewing on paint.
American Journal of Preventive Medicine: Improving Diet and Physical Activity with ALIVE: A Worksite Randomized Trial:
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S074937970...
This randomized controlled trial demonstrated that a 16-week email-delivered intervention significantly increased moderate physical activity by 28 minutes/week (p=0.0002), vigorous activity by 12.5 minutes/week (p=0.03), and fruit and vegetable intake (p=0.03), while reducing saturated fat (–0.95 g/day, p=0.01), trans fat (–0.29 g/day, p=0.02), and sedentary time. Effects were sustained 4 months post-intervention.
American Journal of Public Health: A Computer-Based, Minimal-Contact Intervention to Promote Fruit and Vegetable Consumption:
https://ajph.aphapublications.org/doi/full/10.2105/AJPH.2005...
This randomized controlled trial tested a low-cost, computer-tailored intervention delivered via print or web, targeting increased fruit and vegetable intake over four months. Participants receiving tailored feedback increased intake by 0.85 servings/day versus control (p<0.001). The effect was strongest in those with the lowest baseline intake, and the intervention was effective across both print and web formats, demonstrating broad scalability with minimal in-person contact.
TIME Magazine: Too Fat? Read Your E-Mail:
https://web.archive.org/web/20100628164049/https://time.com/...
A popular summary of the ALIVE! study reporting that brief, tailored weekly emails prompted meaningful improvements in physical activity and diet among employees. Participants increased exercise by 1 hour/week and decreased daily intake of harmful fats by over 1 gram, with measurable public health implications.
You're the paranoid one who believes irrational people are out to silence you, and who calls people you don't even know irrational madmen, when so far nothing like that has happened, therefore the burden of proof for wild unsubstantiated claims is on you.
You asked me to explain it to you. I did. Don't complain you got what you asked for. Now the ball is in your court, to explain what you mean, provide evidence to support it, and prove irrational madmen are out to silence you.
I may be an irrational madman, but I upvoted you, and so far you have not been flagged, and the text of your message is still dark black, which means you have not been downvoted (unless a lot of other people upvoted you to cancel it out, like I did). It looks to me like the moderation system is working as intended.
I already replied to you and your question, and now I'm asking you to TALK, just the opposite of silencing you. Are you accusing me of being one of the irrational madmen out to silence you?
Or are you going to ghost me like you did in those other discussions when you could not provide any evidence for your incorrect claims? Irrational people are not silencing you when you run away with your tail between your legs the first time somebody asks you a question. That's social self-deportation for which you have no one to blame but yourself.
So what exactly are you saying, and what exactly are your beliefs and evidence about lead, nutritional research, questionnaires, analysis, and health care, government funding, and about people being out to silence you?
My position is that lead toxicity seems to be a conspiracy theory, rather than a real thing, the evidence for it is bizarre, and doesn't make any sense, and lead in fact seems to belong where it goes. That is, it's essential, and people are increasingly weak, dumb, and even have deformities because it has been removed.
This comment was instantly downvoted.
Is that it? Are we on the same page? Can you please from now on say what you actually mean instead of being coy and sarcastic and intellectually dishonest, then running away and ghosting me at the first sign of trouble?
So have you read that paper, or not? What does it say that supports or contradicts you point?
Edit 1:
>I didn't ghost you, BTW, my previous account got downvoted so heavily that my posts stopped being visible.
Then the moderation system is working perfectly as designed. In this and other threads of this discussion, and also your comment history, when you're not ghosting, you're sealioning:
>how do you know that lead doesn't belong in the same category as thimerosal, fluoride, or 5G and Wi-Fi?
>What method was used to infer the natural rates?
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sealioning
Don't attempt to sealion me or anyone else again until you've clearly and honestly states your beliefs, and provided evidence for them, as you've been repeatedly asked for, but so far have failed to do.
>It wasn't sarcastic, I tried to make people read it, and see that it's nonsense.
Ok then, if it wasn't sarcastic, it was simply a lie to manipulate people into believing what you do. Well that seems to have had the opposite effect as you intended. So why haven't you replied with any evidence supporting your conspiracy theory yet?
Don't you think that would be easier than trying to dishonestly manipulate people by saying you endorse a paper you don't believe, and calling them names like "irrational madmen"? You need to work on that Trump / RFK Jr. Emulation Game you're playing, you suck at it.
Before "trying to make people read it", when obviously you haven't bothered to read a word I've written, why don't you summarize it and say what you disagree with, to save people time. It's a big paper, and obviously you are quite opinionated and obsessed with it, so I want to hear your opinion, with quotes and citations, please.
Edit 2:
Now that you've discovered how to edit your comments, why don't you finally provide me with some proof of your beliefs? What scientific peer reviewed empirical research papers or random conspiracy theory youtube channel did you get your beliefs from? Links to citations, please. The fact that you quote one paragraph that you can't understand doesn't mean that it's wrong, it means something else, which extremely obvious to everyone, and it's all your own fault.
Here is what the paragraph you quoted means, like you're five:
>Imagine your stomach is like a sponge that soaks up different kinds of ingredients from your food.
>Some ingredients get soaked up a lot, like calcium (from milk), which gets soaked up about half the time.
>Others, like strontium, get soaked up only a little, maybe a quarter of the time.
>Then there's barium, which the sponge barely soaks up — only about 5%.
>Now Mister Scientist is saying:
>“We don’t know exactly how much lead gets soaked up... but if it acts like barium, then people probably only soak up a tiny bit of it too.”
>The scientists are making an estimate based on similar ingredients (calcium, strontium, barium), because they’re in the same “family” on the periodic table (called alkaline earth metals). Lead isn’t exactly the same, but it behaves a bit like them, so he’s using them to guess how much lead the body might absorb from food.
So enough bullshit. If you don't finally provide some solid proof after I've asked you so many times, and you can easily edit your comment for an hour or so, then you'd better give me some evidence right now, or I've proven you're totally full of shit, and you may now ghost me to fulfill my prediction.
Edit 3:
Ok, even after I explained the paragraph you didn't understand to you like you're five, you have just proven that you didn't even bother to read my words, and that you have again totally failed to provide any proof.
Take a step back and look at yourself. Have some self-awareness. The reason you can't provide any proof is because you are wrong, and you know it, and the reason you don't bother to read anything I write is because I am right and I provided you with lots of evidence of that, but you don't want to see it.
Why are you so afraid of admitting that you are wrong, and that you don't have any evidence because there IS no evidence, and your own self-imposed performative ignorance, paranoia, and strategically self serving misunderstanding is proof that you're wrong and you know it. Nobody else believes you. Why do you even pretend to believe yourself, because you don't, otherwise you would have proven what you said long ago.
edit: I don't know why you reply by editing your comment like this. I'm not proposing any conspiracy theory, I'm claiming that lead toxicity is a conspiracy theory. Its proponents kicked out the original experts, forced lead removal, and people are now sick as the result, because the experts were right, and the normal levels were in fact normal.
There is nothing much to agree or disagree with in the paper, because it's entirely nonsensical. He pulls out random numbers, and makes an illogical conclusion supposedly based on them.
>The approximate fractions of alkaline earths absorbed by the intestine upon ingestion are: calcium 50%; strontium 25%; and barium 5%. If the alimentary absorption factor for lead in food is similar to that for barium, the amount of lead naturally absorbed by man is...
And it's the entire paper like this.
Edit2: No, it isn't because I don't uderstand it. I can read scientific papers, and this doesn't even look or read as one. It's nonsense written by a geochemist who went crazy.
Edit3: No, you can't randomly assume something, and base your conclusions on that. How did you get that idea?
I took what he said at face value, gave him the best possible interpretation and benefit of the doubt, that he was sincerely endorsing a well respected credible research paper. What more do you ask? It's not on me that he was lying and manipulating and insincere. Maybe you should be criticizing him for not upholding the spirit of HN.
I've even upvoted him, have you?
So why don't you try to get some evidence out of him with some of your famously extreme politeness? Have a go at it. But it looks like he's ghosted us, as I predicted.
Or maybe you can try rationally explaining his position, and giving me some evidence on his behalf, if you believe him, since he doesn't seem to be able to produce any himself.
Or are you one of those irrational madmen he keeps raving about who wants to silence him? Come to think of it, I haven't heard from him in a while, and his mysterious disappearance coincides with your arrival, the two of you never having been seen in the same room together at once... Hmmm. POOF!!! What did you do??? Did you eliminate him yourself somehow??! 'Twasn't me!
THAT is the very definition of lying. So it's totally fair for me to accuse you of lying, because at first I patiently gave you the benefit of the doubt and best possible interpretation that you were telling the truth, then after that, you admitted you were not telling the truth and actually didn't endorse the paper like you said, once again I generously gave you the benefit of the doubt and best possible interpretation that you were only being sarcastic, and then YOU denied THAT too.
Therefore, you were lying, and you admitted that by denying both of my best possible interpretations and confirming twice that you did not actually mean what you said, and that your intent was to manipulate people's behavior by saying the opposite of what you really believed.
Don't blame me for your own words and lies and repeated intellectually dishonest attempts at manipulation by not telling the truth. You're a liar. There is no other charitable interpretation. End of discussion.
Now you're making a whole lot more non-credible unbelievable claims without presenting a shred of evidence, after I've asked you for evidence again and again.
What I am trying to do is to get an answer out of you, so now that you've thrown yet another paranoid infantile tantrum about your self pity and false victimhood, why don't you BREAK YOUR SELF IMPOSED SILENCE and finally answer my question:
WHAT IS YOUR EVIDENCE?
This is the seminal paper of the hero who proved it all. Go ahead, if you are being rational with all this, and not just a group of madmen, go ahead and explain it to me.
https://sci-hub.se/https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/14334042/