Re:The Singularity is not coming
by shaggyfrog on Friday August 10, 2012 @02:00AM
(#4365126)
I like your highway analogy. Mainly I think the singularity argument suffers from an acute case of perception bias in favour of recent advancements; just as picking any arbitrary point in time and asking a scientist of that era what they thought the most important scientific advancements were.
> We can't imagine the tools that will be in use in 2112.
Pretty much just the hall-filling computers of the Priests of the Temples of Syrinx. Guitar-smashing jerks.
I think it's an example of ruthless extrapolation.
http://www.energybulletin.net/stories/2012-06-27/ruthless-ex...
Re:The Singularity is not coming
by snowwrestler on Friday August 10, 2012 @10:24AM
(#4366271)
Ha! It was so hard to resist a Rush reference when I wrote that date.
Well, I mean when you look at some of the incredibly broken tools that we use today, it is a bit ridiculous:
1). Emacs/Vim are the popular hardcore/moddable editors, despite the severe clunkiness/outdated architecture
2). C/C++ has a huge mindshare despite the fact that it severely reduces the impact of the individual programmer
3). Proprietary tools are falling away, but their entrenched closed gardens are remaining for us to take care of
4). OS design has almost stalled
I think big paradigm shifts are coming at much faster rates than anyone wants to admit. If you are looking at the past to predict what comes tomorrow, you are an idiot, at least in the field of computing. I feel like we are standing on the precipice of a hole so scary no one really wants to look down at it.
OT Emacs clunkiness/outdated architecture...give me a break, minimal
core with lisp interpreter on top giving programmable and extensible
platform next to none is still what...30 years ahead of anything called
"modern".
I'm not saying that there is something superior atm, I'm just saying it could be SO much better than what it is today.
I have yet to find anything vim can't do that I'd like it to do. Like most critics you only make vague statements. Anyway, the source is out there, if there really was a need for new features somebody would implement them. Hint, hint!
Re:The Singularity is not coming
by saint-loup on Friday August 10, 2012 @04:43AM
(#4365449)
This is akin to the so-called AI effect: "AI is whatever hasn't been done yet". http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/AI_effect
Basically I believe it's an issue of cultural time perspective. We can't imagine the tools that will be in use in 2112. But, they won't seem so strange to the people of 2111.