News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Agent2Agent Protocol (A2A) by echelon on Thursday April 10, 2025 @12:20AM (#43640586)
> WSDLs and XSDs done right are a godsend for transmitting your API spec to someone. I use .NET and can call xsd.exe to generate classes from the files in a few seconds.

This sounds like protobuf and gRPC. Is that a close analogy?

Re:The Agent2Agent Protocol (A2A) by nsonha on Thursday April 10, 2025 @01:17AM (#43640868)
The latter would add subscription and streaming, and more efficient transports. But yeah they are basically the same idea.

I hate that for years the concept of RPC was equated to XML which in turn equated to some implementation of the (XML based) tool and then a whole lot of distracting discourse around XML vs JSON, we kinda do still have that these days with yaml vs whatever.

Re:The Agent2Agent Protocol (A2A) by bob1029 on Thursday April 10, 2025 @05:39AM (#43642294)
It's like those things, but I've never seen protobuf or gRPC used for APIs this extensive.

The tooling around these paths is also lackluster by comparison if you're using something like Visual Studio.

I'd rather fight XML namespaces and HTTP/1.1 transports than sort through the wreckage of what "best practices" has recently brought to bear - especially in terms of unattended complexity in large, legacy enterprises. Explaining to a small bank in Ohio that they're going to need to adjust all of their firewalls to accommodate some new protocols is a total nonstarter in my business.