Goodbye, Hacker News. I'm going back to Reddit.

Re:Goodbye, Hacker News. I'm going back to Reddit. by palish on Friday August 17, 2007 @06:25PM (#43639)

Wait, what? Dude, a story that's submitted should be titled the same regardless of who submits the story. The only variance in titles should be mere semantics. Any extra information in the title only adds bias or spelling/grammar mistakes. Therefore, editing a title to its correct form is just fine. Relax.

But if you can't relax, goodbye. If this thread title is any indication, you produce great Reddit/Digg titles.

I hope Paul changes "title: " to "suggest a title: " on the submission page so people realize it's not their title. They didn't produce the content, and if they did then the editors aren't retitle it.

[ Parent | on HN ]

Re:Goodbye, Hacker News. I'm going back to Reddit. by aston on Friday August 17, 2007 @06:34PM (#43645)

I actually think this is sort of a dumb argument to get into in the first place, but you have to admit that not letting the original submitters to own their titles (when you allow them to own the resulting karma) is kind of inconsistent.

Ultimately, though, this sort of user revolt is bound to happen whenever you make major changes to how a community works. I think news.yc'll make it with or without the people who are pissed.

[ Parent | on HN ]

Re:Goodbye, Hacker News. I'm going back to Reddit. by palish on Friday August 17, 2007 @06:36PM (#43646)

".. not letting the original submitters to own their titles (when you allow them to own their resulting karma) is kind of inconsistent."

I don't see how a user owns a title to content they didn't produce. If they produced it, the editors won't change it.

You get karma for bringing quality content to other people's attention, not for calling the content something it isn't.

[ Parent | on HN ]

Re:Goodbye, Hacker News. I'm going back to Reddit. by aston on Saturday August 18, 2007 @06:23PM (#43909)

Well, I've personally had titles edited, all for stylistic issues (none for bias, innaccuracy, or anything I'd deem worth editing). I don't really care, but I would prefer that unless my submissions were clearly in need of correction that they were not changed. They do show up under "submissions" clicking from my profile, so I think they ought to reflect what I submitted unless it harms the site.

[ Parent | on HN ]

Re:Goodbye, Hacker News. I'm going back to Reddit. by budu3 on Friday August 17, 2007 @08:56PM (#43679)

You make a good point. Do we really own the titles? If we don't own it, then who does? The hacker news community, the editors? I guess if we don't then we need to change our mindsets. Is that why we can't delete the submissions we make?

[ Parent | on HN ]

Re:Goodbye, Hacker News. I'm going back to Reddit. by dfranke on Friday August 17, 2007 @09:15PM (#43683)

Wha? You can delete your own submissions. Just yesterday I submitted the RMS earthquake story before nickb did, but then deleted it after reading the Reddit comments on the same story and seeing that it was inaccurate.

[ Parent | on HN ]

Re:Goodbye, Hacker News. I'm going back to Reddit. by rms on Friday August 17, 2007 @09:49PM (#43688)

You can only delete/edit them for one hour after submission.

[ Parent | on HN ]