Re:Show HN: Sell your stuff for more money with less hassle
by aeturnum on Thursday August 09, 2012 @06:21PM
(#4363607)
In your example, I tried bidding $20,000 (I really love the couch) and you asked me to come down to $1500. Is there a reason you're steering buyers towards a minimum price?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Show HN: Sell your stuff for more money with less hassle
by bunkat on Thursday August 09, 2012 @06:24PM
(#4363623)
Prevents people from making ridiculous offers, especially by mistake. We want buyers to come away from BidKat feeling just as good as the seller.
Re:Show HN: Sell your stuff for more money with less hassle
by aeturnum on Thursday August 09, 2012 @06:30PM
(#4363661)
I think that's a good impulse, but completely refusing the bid seems misguided.
The current system seems like it favors predatory buyers over fair ones. If the seller undervalues their item, trying to start at a fair price will get rejected. I don't know how you selected the [500 1500] envelope on price, but it seems pretty narrow. Couldn't you just warn the bidder that their bid is way above the seller's expectations (or current maximum offer) and then confirm they want to pay that much?
Re:Show HN: Sell your stuff for more money with less hassle
by bunkat on Thursday August 09, 2012 @06:35PM
(#4363686)
We can definitely look into this if we see this happening a lot. This should be a relative edge case and only kicks in for more expensive items, but you are right that there are other options.
Re:Show HN: Sell your stuff for more money with less hassle
by lewisflude on Thursday August 09, 2012 @06:52PM
(#4363760)
Is there any chance you can add in a way to remove obviously fake bids? If too many users abuse the system it could ruin the functionality of the virtual cat that haggles with potential buyers.
For instance, someone might do a real bid of $500 (let's call them bidder A), but if there's a fake bid of $2000, would the virtual cat try and make bidder A bid higher than $2000?
Re:Show HN: Sell your stuff for more money with less hassle
by bunkat on Thursday August 09, 2012 @07:03PM
(#4363818)
No, BidKat doesn't work like that. He works with each buyer individually to come up with the price that they find fair and that meets the sellers price requirements.
Re:Show HN: Sell your stuff for more money with less hassle
by lewisflude on Friday August 10, 2012 @07:01AM
(#4365689)
That's great. Works fine for me. Once again, congrats.