News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:John Carmack on AI in game programming by dmarcos on Monday April 07, 2025 @03:07PM (#43614772)
What’s your opinion of Youtube? We were better off when just a few could create and distribute video at scale?

There was similar criticism to yours when the printing press was invented.

Re:John Carmack on AI in game programming by fullshark on Monday April 07, 2025 @03:14PM (#43614833)
Or maybe the music industry? I feel like there's more music than ever, but none of it seems to be of much value and/or lasting cultural impact. It doesn't seem like it's gotten better with easier accessibility to tools, just there's a lot more options for you if you are a fan of a certain genre.

I can see games being similar, maybe a few creative people invent new genres never seen before, or mix elements in creative ways with AI tools, but I'm guessing it will more likely mean a lot of slight variations of games that bring in money churned out quickly.

Re:John Carmack on AI in game programming by gwbas1c on Monday April 07, 2025 @03:55PM (#43615266)
> I feel like there's more music than ever, but none of it seems to be of much value and/or lasting cultural impact.

It's always been that way, especially before mass-produced recordings were available.

The "Beatles" period was partly because you had to choose wisely what you were going to spend your limited dollars on when you went to the record shop.

The difference today is that recording technology is cheap, and, with streaming, you don't have to "choose wisely" when you go to the record store. Now all of the mediocre artists, who were generally excluded from the "Beatles" period, can get on streaming platforms.

BTW: There's awesome music coming out today. It just takes time for word to spread.

Re:John Carmack on AI in game programming by ironman1478 on Monday April 07, 2025 @03:18PM (#43614880)
I think when it comes to music, it's really disheartening to hear people say it hasn't gotten better. There is a lot of good music coming out in so many genres, but it really requires actively seeking it out.
Re:John Carmack on AI in game programming by fullshark on Monday April 07, 2025 @03:20PM (#43614895)
I've dug pretty deep in the genres I like...it's just all slight variations imo of the work the trendsetting artists did establishing the genre in the first place as far as I can tell.
Re:John Carmack on AI in game programming by lostmsu on Monday April 07, 2025 @05:12PM (#43616002)
You might have just gotten older.
Re:John Carmack on AI in game programming by hlfshell on Monday April 07, 2025 @03:23PM (#43614913)
The issue is that as music progresses and changes so too does distribution networks. Traditional, or even nontraditional to those from the pre spotify internet days, pipelines of music discovery have been largely co-opted by industry. Outlets of organic discovery are different now - and people typically don't continually keep changing their habits enough to keep up with it.

Pair this with the fact that most people settle their musical tastes to be in line with when they are experiencing the most emotionally significant time in their early lives (high school for some, college for others, etc) and the result is an assumption that

A) What they encounter forms an overall opinion of "all" new music despite being the tip of the iceberg and

B) It's not as good as what they grew up on

Re:John Carmack on AI in game programming by johnnyanmac on Monday April 07, 2025 @09:58PM (#43617676)
Because algorithmic curation shifted from what's quality to what's "sellable". That's a part of why you get sentiments that "media got worse". Hardcore media fans will still scour and find proper curations themselves (or be he curator), but the default of just letting Spotify or Netflix tell what's "quality" is long over.

Another little cut on why people are trusting big tech less ad less.

Re:John Carmack on AI in game programming by falcor84 on Monday April 07, 2025 @03:21PM (#43614903)
> I feel like there's more music than ever, but none of it seems to be of much value and/or lasting cultural impact.

I'm sorry, but this seems exactly like what every single generation says. I'm pretty sure that I read some similar quotes aimed at the Beatles back in the 60s.

Re:John Carmack on AI in game programming by fullshark on Monday April 07, 2025 @03:31PM (#43615000)
I've thought of that, but there is a trend of a retreat from newer music, this isn't just a generation gap speaking.

https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2022/01/old-music-...

A lot of what's happening is imo is just there's so much more competition for attention, and music has lost value as a cultural force beyond the music itself for younger people than it used to have, when young people would develop parasocial relationships or "crushes" or build their self-identity on pop stars and their fandom. A lot of this power culturally has been balkanized.

Speaking of the music itself, once the economic incentive is removed to create great songs (we are there already) we will get fewer great songs. That force is countering the fact that we have more tools and distribution channels than ever to create great songs, and those two forces are in opposition and to me, it seems like the fewer great songs force is winning (subjective).

Re:John Carmack on AI in game programming by keybored on Monday April 07, 2025 @03:25PM (#43614929)
> Or maybe the music industry? I feel like there's more music than ever, but none of it seems to be of much value and/or lasting cultural impact. It doesn't seem like it's gotten better with easier accessibility to tools, just there's a lot more options for you if you are a fan of a certain genre.

You both listen to so much music and have a palette that is so wide-ranging that you can somewhat objectively judge it as not having gotten better?

Re:John Carmack on AI in game programming by fullshark on Monday April 07, 2025 @03:33PM (#43615017)
How do you objectively judge that? It's just my opinion, value that for what its worth to you (sounds like not much).
Re:John Carmack on AI in game programming by keybored on Wednesday April 09, 2025 @12:14PM (#43633744)
I gave leeway with “somewhat objectively” but do shy away from your wide-sweeping statement immediately for all I care.
Re:John Carmack on AI in game programming by galleywest200 on Monday April 07, 2025 @03:09PM (#43614802)
Good points, but it is worth considering that in both of those scenarios you listed the content within the end product is fully created by a human and not generated by a machine.
Re:John Carmack on AI in game programming by codybontecou on Monday April 07, 2025 @03:12PM (#43614821)
That’s severely discounting the machines used to generate the video content.
Re:John Carmack on AI in game programming by johnnyanmac on Monday April 07, 2025 @10:01PM (#43617690)
The machine is "compiling" the video, not taking the creative helm.

That was the relationship we had for some 200 years. The machine automates and accelerates the predictable labor, and the creative heads composes and conducts the tasks.

As of late, we seem to want to flip the script under the guise that "we can make more content" without considering the impact on the creative process. Not how to drive the output, but just how to make more and more. Creativity be damned. That's the issue.

Re:John Carmack on AI in game programming by dmarcos on Monday April 07, 2025 @10:23PM (#43617799)
AI is just another form of automation that replaces more of the manual labor. Humans still driving it. How do you feel about photography that replaced portrait paintings? Or photoshop filters? Or computer animation vs hand drawn? I don't see any difference with AI. You can indeed let the AI output stuff automatically but it's as interesting as stock photography. Do you disagree with Carmack's assessment?

"AI tools will allow the best to reach even greater heights, while enabling smaller teams to accomplish more, and bring in some completely new creator demographics"

Re:John Carmack on AI in game programming by johnnyanmac on Tuesday April 08, 2025 @02:39AM (#43618946)
Unlike a camera, these new automation still need require paintings. That why I don't consider generative AI as true iteration. It's literally stealing the town's paintingsand using it to mash together this collage that's called "art" . Why would I call that "progress"? You're making metaphorically uglier horses, but you're boasting about breeding them faster. We wee not worried about breeding more horses to begin with.

>You can indeed let the AI output stuff automatically but it's as interesting as stock photograp

Yes. And stock photography had agreements with the photographer. Much of the art scraped explicity said not to. It's not interesting and potentially illegal. The worst of both worlds.

>Do you disagree with Carmack's assessment?

I left a top level response somewhere, but overall, c. 2025 : not really. It feels like more hype generation, and this isn't the first time he's had to be a hype man. Maybe one day, maybe before or after we get convinent VR/AR hardware. It'll be a while.

And no small team is touching this stuff whike the courts battle about this. Come back to me in 5 years when the ethics is settled and the tech might be more ready. It's pretty hard to even look 5 weeks ahead in these times, let alone 5 years.

Re:John Carmack on AI in game programming by numpad0 on Monday April 07, 2025 @04:01PM (#43615330)
I think it's ok to add selective pressure whenever spammy, unethical, low-quality content starts flooding the system. Books has copyright laws and resistive book distribution channels, YouTube has Likes and moderation systems, etc.

With hindsight, one of silent assumptions very common of both pro- and anti-AI arguments up to this point was as follows: because AI is potentially superhuman in arts, the existing selective pressures could inversely punish desired creativity if AI outputs were not unfairly treated. Pro-AI arguments assumed that warping the system is wrong, anti-AI assumed allowing the system go down is worse. IMO, superhuman AI didn't happen anyway, and so now AI slop problem is just spam control problem.

No one was ever against punishing spams and unethical actors. It's fine and safe. We're at a postmortem phase during which we'd patch the bugs in laws and law enforcement that allowed AI companies do outlandish hacks like torrenting books and redistributing it as lossy compressed 500GB GGUF.

Re:John Carmack on AI in game programming by flashgordon on Monday April 07, 2025 @03:11PM (#43614813)
Yeah this is where my own internal conflict is too. May be this cheap flooding is required to bring down the cost of creation so the truly high quality games/content creates by the top 1% will be valued more (though finding would be much harder?)?
Re:John Carmack on AI in game programming by codybontecou on Monday April 07, 2025 @03:14PM (#43614835)
We moved from a content generation problem to a search problem.
Re:John Carmack on AI in game programming by bryanlarsen on Monday April 07, 2025 @03:17PM (#43614873)
It was always a search problem.
Re:John Carmack on AI in game programming by flashgordon on Monday April 07, 2025 @03:21PM (#43614899)
Yeah this was where I was getting to. Are the content enablers enabling flooding of content so now they can start selling the search tools/tactics. Wonder if this another way of creating a pandemic so you can sell a cure haha
Re:John Carmack on AI in game programming by bryanlarsen on Monday April 07, 2025 @03:23PM (#43614916)
I think we're saying different things. In 1977 finding a good video game amongst the drek was difficult. It was a search problem in 1977, it's a search problem in 2025.

Sturgeon's law. 90% of everything is, and always will be, drek.

Re:John Carmack on AI in game programming by flashgordon on Monday April 07, 2025 @05:32PM (#43616181)
Interesting. But was the drek in 1977 because flooding the game market was "easy" (I meant to say game development was hard in 1977 - I think - so if there was really drel back then was there a high supply then that was the cause of it?
Re:John Carmack on AI in game programming by johnnyanmac on Monday April 07, 2025 @10:05PM (#43617698)
The platform providers are enabling the flooding of content so that they get to become the curator and influence minds. Even general search is just an an ad pusher followed by whoever pays up to show up high, then followed by whoever games the system the best.

There's no incentive to fix it because they control the information and profit off the situation. The system is working as intended.

Re:John Carmack on AI in game programming by prisenco on Monday April 07, 2025 @03:17PM (#43614871)
There's a valid argument to be made there though. We possibly were better off when tastemakers managed to filter out the lowest common denominator.

When you think of Youtube, you might think of pretty decent stuff but you have to remember the absolute slop like Spiderman/Elsa videos, crude ripoffs and near porn gets many, many more views than the good stuff.

I'm not saying strict gatekeeping is necessary, but open systems are an absolute minefield for humanity. That's clear to me after the last 10 years or so.

Re:John Carmack on AI in game programming by dmarcos on Monday April 07, 2025 @03:35PM (#43615043)
I don’t mind the slop. Filtering and discovery is a solvable issue. I care about tons of niche and educational content that I enjoy that would not exist if it had to be funded / approved by gatekeepers.
Re:John Carmack on AI in game programming by prisenco on Monday April 07, 2025 @03:55PM (#43615259)
I believe it's more complicated than saying slop is required for niche and education content.

That said, we've already decided that truly open systems are not viable. That was settled years ago. Now even 4chan has rules.

Right now we have algorithms that promote terrible content based on automated metrics that don't make the good stuff any easier to find. Especially considering the consolidation of platforms into a few hegemonic sites.

In that sense we already have gatekeeping, it's just a terrible approach to it.

And for the record I mind the slop because of how easily it drowns out and eventually overtakes the good stuff. Even good, educational content feels the need to cater to the algorithm to survive.

We're not at a tipping point yet, but it certainly feels we're headed in that direction.

Algorithmically promoting tastemakers might be a solution. Pushing the good content to the top and burying the slop.

Re:John Carmack on AI in game programming by AstralStorm on Monday April 07, 2025 @05:31PM (#43616171)
Unfortunately a big chunk of the public likes the taste of the slop, or is too nostalgic or reticent to try anything new.

Sometimes the new thing is also unpolished and needs work, perhaps even a second artist to pick it up and make it good...

Re:John Carmack on AI in game programming by prisenco on Monday April 07, 2025 @06:04PM (#43616460)
My desire for tastemakers and gatekeepers and the majority of people consuming the lowest common denominator of content when left to their own devices aren't at odds. In fact, it's part of the equation.
Re:John Carmack on AI in game programming by johnnyanmac on Monday April 07, 2025 @10:07PM (#43617718)
I mind but can fiter the slop. That's every media platform these days.

I very much mind the theft. Even Youtube is offering ways to just "generate new videos" which is done by outright stealing from other youtubers.

Re:John Carmack on AI in game programming by camillomiller on Monday April 07, 2025 @03:17PM (#43614862)
This comparison suffers from what I call “the scale phallacy”. You can’t compare disrupting technologies like this as if the scale of their impact plays no role at all. How many people’s livelihood depended on monks writing books by hand?
Re:John Carmack on AI in game programming by falcor84 on Monday April 07, 2025 @03:26PM (#43614950)
Arguably all the tens of millions of those whose lives depended on the hegemony of the Catholic church and the status quo it maintained. The disruption was relatively slow, but massive.
Re:John Carmack on AI in game programming by teamonkey on Monday April 07, 2025 @03:34PM (#43615034)
Pentiment (2022)
Re:John Carmack on AI in game programming by techpineapple on Monday April 07, 2025 @03:15PM (#43614844)
> What’s your opinion of Youtube? We were better off when just a few could create and distribute video at scale?

Yes, I think I would make that argument.

But also I think I’m making a different argument. The game market already seems to be pretty flooded. I think many people see it as “we get more great indie games”, but I wonder if we don’t get less. That it creates more of a bipolar distribution. Triple-A relatively unaffected, and more vaporware games but it hollows out the middle.

I also think that “we objected to earlier progress and it turned out ok, therefor all objections to progress are bad” is a logical fallacy.

Re:John Carmack on AI in game programming by AstralStorm on Monday April 07, 2025 @05:32PM (#43616184)
What is actually showing up is more asset dumps, rather unimaginative variations on a game.

Often seen as job simulator games because they're so formulaic.

Sometimes you see unimaginative remixes like Palworld.

Re:John Carmack on AI in game programming by keybored on Monday April 07, 2025 @04:54PM (#43615832)
> There was similar criticism to yours when the printing press was invented.

A similar thing was discussed in the past, checkmate.

We have this commonsense whig-history where everything became a little bit better century by century. But one could argue that the printing press makes propaganda possible. From that you get thought control by the elite. Now you ironically get an elitist outcome, or an elite-benefiting outcome.

Was the printing press a net good? Maybe it’s more complicated than “more books good”.

Re:John Carmack on AI in game programming by dmarcos on Monday April 07, 2025 @05:47PM (#43616301)
Would you go back to a pre-youtube, pre-printing press, pre-internet, pre-pick-your—favorite-tecnology that democratized content creation and distribution? I know I wouldn’t.
Re:John Carmack on AI in game programming by keybored on Tuesday April 08, 2025 @03:57PM (#43625828)
I would not with the snap of a finger revert back to a time centuries ago when I have spent all my life up until now learning to live in the current one. No. Just like a tribal Papua New Guinean would not want to, with the snap of the finger, become one of the vice presidents in the American Psycho movie. He wouldn’t know what to do with himself.

Beyond that I don’t know what there is to say about our so-called democratizing technologies when the discussion gets reduced to—and never goes beyond—those very slogans about them being democratizing. Yes. We are now free to repeat the same slogans that everyone else repeats.