Re:Amazon forces Unglue.it to Suspend Crowdfunding for Creat...
by nikcub on Thursday August 09, 2012 @12:53PM
(#4361943)
I never understood how the semantics of a crowdfunding payment are any different to when your credit card is taken on file at a hotel for room charge bills.
You hand over your credit card upfront in anticipation of a possible payment in the future.
I think the real problem here is classifying crowd funding as a product purchase or an investment.
Re:Amazon forces Unglue.it to Suspend Crowdfunding for Creat...
by tomp on Thursday August 09, 2012 @01:12PM
(#4362053)
Why do they allow it for kickstarter (as stated in the article)?
Is it possible the reason is because kickstarter is not interfering with their primary business?
Re:Amazon forces Unglue.it to Suspend Crowdfunding for Creat...
by ayelton on Thursday August 09, 2012 @01:18PM
(#4362078)
They've given us the impression that they're not onboarding new crowdfunding companies, but KS is not new. I haven't heard any comment from Amazon about Kickstarter specifically and I'm not going to speculate.
Re:Amazon forces Unglue.it to Suspend Crowdfunding for Creat...
by DennisP on Thursday August 09, 2012 @11:18AM
(#4361427)
Why is it a grey area? Which regulations?
Seems like a pretty straightforward transaction to me.
Re:Amazon forces Unglue.it to Suspend Crowdfunding for Creat...
by milesskorpen on Thursday August 09, 2012 @11:24AM
(#4361464)
At least for Kickstarter, a lot of people seem to think of their payments as part of a transaction ... while they aren't. My understanding is that there are a number of Kickstarters which never produced the promised rewards / end output, and that they have no legal obligation to do so.
Re:Amazon forces Unglue.it to Suspend Crowdfunding for Creat...
by adgar on Thursday August 09, 2012 @11:22AM
(#4361456)
Money laundering is the first giant red flag that should come to mind.
Re:Amazon forces Unglue.it to Suspend Crowdfunding for Creat...
by ScottBurson on Thursday August 09, 2012 @01:10PM
(#4362040)
At first glance, I suppose there would be that potential. I think unglue.it has chosen their business model very wisely. By starting with already-published books, they make money laundering rather difficult to carry out and easy to detect -- to launder money through their service, one would first have to publish a book, which would probably have to sell a significant number of copies for unglue.it to even consider it.
Re:Amazon forces Unglue.it to Suspend Crowdfunding for Creat...
by DennisP on Friday August 10, 2012 @01:33PM
(#4367229)
Any brick-and-mortar shop that accepts cash and charges a lot for labor can be used for money-laundering, but that doesn't make it illegal.
An online business is actually less useful for laundering than the brick-and-mortar shop, since you don't have cash payments.
Amazon is not the first to suspend taking on such accounts until they have better grip on the regulatory implications.