News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Rsync replaced with openrsync on macOS Sequoia by ninkendo on Sunday April 06, 2025 @06:51PM (#43605668)
If you make a device which uses GPL’d code, and provide all the covered source code you used, but prevent users from putting any modified code on the device, you are in violation of GPLv3, but not GPLv2. That means this sentence:

> I could ship a GPLv3 system tomorrow that disallows user root access and as long as I make the OS source freely available and redistributable, it's fine.

Is not true for gpl3. It’s called the “tivo-ization” loophole, and it’s one of the principal reasons the GPL3 was made in the first place. I think you’re just wrong.

(Note: I’m not claiming Apple is would be in violation for shipping e.g. a GPLv3 bash on macOS, today, only that they would be in violation for doing that on iOS today, or if in the future they locked down macOS in the same way that iOS was, then for macOS too.)

Re:Rsync replaced with openrsync on macOS Sequoia by pabs3 on Monday April 07, 2025 @03:43AM (#43608910)
Correction, that is a GPLv2 violation too. Some discussion:

https://lwn.net/Articles/858905/