News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What If We Made Advertising Illegal? by SoftTalker on Saturday April 05, 2025 @07:10PM (#43597561)
As a fantasy it sounds nice but it immediately hits the wall of the 1st amendment.
Re:What If We Made Advertising Illegal? by cookingrobot on Saturday April 05, 2025 @08:53PM (#43598068)
How is that? There are lots of things that are illegal that are just “speech”.

Fraud, threats, impersonation, etc etc.

Re:What If We Made Advertising Illegal? by wskish on Saturday April 05, 2025 @09:19PM (#43598187)
Amplified messaging from corporations is not the same as the free speech of individuals. Just as we disallow advertising for cigarettes and hard liquor on TV, a democratic society should be free to select other classes of messages that corporations are not permitted to amplify into public spaces.
Re:What If We Made Advertising Illegal? by twoodfin on Saturday April 05, 2025 @10:38PM (#43598522)
Hard liquor ads are all over (e.g.) broadcasts of NFL games.

Cigarette advertising “bans” are not legislated, IIRC, but a result of the various consolidated settlements of the 1990s-era lawsuits against the tobacco companies. They’re essentially voluntary, and it’s not obvious that a genuine ban would survive constitutional scrutiny. It might: Commercial speech is among the least protected forms of speech.

But at some point a line is crossed: Painting “Read the New York Times” on the side of a barn you own is bread & butter freedom of expression.

Re:What If We Made Advertising Illegal? by TomasBM on Sunday April 06, 2025 @05:28AM (#43600126)
Outside the US (e.g., Europe), advertising bans for tobacco and liquor can work quite well.

Sure, there will always be bad cases and loopholes - even bans on murder don't work 100% - but there's a reason "bans" are still a viable mechanism.

Re:What If We Made Advertising Illegal? by const_cast on Sunday April 06, 2025 @01:52PM (#43603364)
> But at some point a line is crossed: Painting “Read the New York Times” on the side of a barn you own is bread & butter freedom of expression.

Okay, then don't make that illegal.

I don't understand this mentality of "everything is the same as everything else so we can't do anything".

Sure, it's all just scale. But scale matters. Scale is why I can do a science experiment at home and it's cool, but I can't make a nuclear warhead. Seems for just about everything we've been able to find that line and work around it. This "we've tried nothing and we're all out of ideas" approach to society is toxic, and we need to stop.

Re:What If We Made Advertising Illegal? by GuinansEyebrows on Saturday April 05, 2025 @11:25PM (#43598743)
Yeah unfortunately Citizens United really did a number on the judicial stance on funded “speech”
Re:What If We Made Advertising Illegal? by xrortrad on Sunday April 06, 2025 @08:33AM (#43601004)
It doesn't sound nice. It sounds utterly insane and totalitarian.

There is such a disturbing element of society that seems to want to "save democracy" by any means necessary. By "save democracy" they mean get the election results they want, in other words it has nothing at all to do with democracy.

They just want power.

"We should ban advertising so the people I agree with can have absolute power" is really what these insane people are saying.