Instead, we are seeing countries match with import tariffs in the other direction, and a deterioration of global trust.
I don't think most countries actually want to balance bilateral trade. You can get a hint of this by the fact that the calculation that the US is using right now to determine the tariff rate puts a floor of 10% tariff. If they were truly committed to balancing bilateral trade then you would have expected them to actually have added export tariffs to any countries where the US had a trade surplus. Instead they gave a 10% import tariff still. I'm not sure I've seen any explanation for this 10%.
Right, because e.g. if Canada has no tariff on car imports and the USA has tariffs, then the logical course of action for car manufacturers is to move all of their manufacturing for Canadian-sold cars to the US, because it's more flexible to have manufacturing in the place that incurs fewer tariffs overall. Canadian import tariffs take that incentive away.
Export tariffs make more sense for resources where the manufacturing base can't be moved.
So the orange idiot can make a "deal".
Not if you want to avoid escalation of a trade war.
If you know that the US is pissed off because you're hoarding dollars because its the reserve currency and its causing the USD to rise too high, leading to their decline in manufacturing competitiveness, then you can solve their problem for them by adding an export tariff. It will make them more competitive. But that way, you get the revenues from the tariff rather than the US. Adding your own import tariffs makes the trade balance worse. Its like the person you're negotiating with is complaining about a knife and you decide to twist it rather than remove it. A 50/50 split of export and import tariffs would mean that both countries can take a cut, the USD can maintain reserve status, and US manufacturing can stay competitive despite a stronger dollar. The fact that noone is doing this means that either they haven't considered it or they aren't happy with this outcome(probably the latter, but you never know...)
But you don’t know that! The explicit US position is that their tariffs are purely retaliatory, based on a formula they invented a few days ago which claims to compute an effective rate consisting of tariffs and non-tariff barriers. Export tariffs would make the formula as currently constructed go down, but the US would clearly see you’re juking the stats rather than actually removing trade barriers, and adjust the formula to account for it.
Perhaps you think the US is being strategically deceptive about its motivations? I do see a lot of people offer that as a “defense” of the US position, although I don’t clearly understand how this is meant to make things better. How should foreign trade negotiators know which HN commenters are telling them the real position and which ones have been taken in by the misdirection?
I'd contrast this with the Obama energy policy, which was a significant change in US policy toward energy independence, consistently and fairly quietly applied without generating a worldwide recession or trade war.
https://www.investing.com/news/politics-news/investment-comm...
It doesn't cost the UAE a penny to do Trump a favor by announcing a $1.4T investment. Let's see if they actually spend a penny.
> it is better for a country to have a diverse manufacturing base
A country can exist and be wealthy without diverse manufacturing base.
> a net positive balance of trade
A country can have stable and growing economy with negative balance of trade, as long as certain conditions are met. In short, this country may offer something else to compensate trade deficit, i.e. there can be a price tag on military and political power.
This theory has yet to be tested in a peer war.
And what about services the US provides? Google and Microsoft are some of the biggest companies and bring a ton of money to the US, but this doesn't seem to be included in the calculation because they don't sell physical goods.
Are they? Or do they keep their profits overseas?
Trade deficit in physical goods: $1.2T
Total services exports, including finance and IT: $1.1T
Trade surplus in services: $295B (just 25% of what is needed)
It's interesting to see how the U.S. could make it happen though, given that there is already a shortage of labor and materials. It will be a long, long road.
You didn’t ask for counter arguments but I’m sure we will see a wide range below this comment.
A broader picture here is to say neoliberal globalization is bad in that it removes local autonomy by creating a need for peaceful trading partners. Who is it bad for, and what sort of world would be good for those people is an exercise left to the reader.
EDIT: I like the vigorous comments and zero net score on this comment. don't blame the messenger guys, this is a fair statement of the steelman. It does not represent my own views.