News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:AI 2027 by kridsdale3 on Thursday April 03, 2025 @05:29PM (#43575677)
TBH, this kind of reads like the pedigrees of the former members of the OpenAI board. When the thing blew up, and people started to apply real scrutiny, it turned out that about half of them had no real experience in pretty much anything at all, except founding Foundations and instituting Institutes.

A lot of people (like the Effective Altruism cult) seem to have made a career out of selling their Sci-Fi content as policy advice.

Re:AI 2027 by flappyeagle on Thursday April 03, 2025 @05:39PM (#43575792)
c'mon man, you don't believe that, let's have a little less disingenuousness on the internet
Re:AI 2027 by arduanika on Thursday April 03, 2025 @07:59PM (#43576896)
How would you know what he believes?

There's hype and there's people calling bullshit. If you work from the assumption that the hype people are genuine, but the people calling bullshit can't be for real, that's how you get a bubble.

Re:AI 2027 by flappyeagle on Friday April 04, 2025 @05:24PM (#43587725)
Because they are not the same in any way. It’s not a bunch of junior academics, it’s literally including someone who worked at OpenAI
Re:AI 2027 by arduanika on Saturday April 05, 2025 @03:06PM (#43595966)
You're right it's not a bunch of junior academics. It's not even a bunch of junior academics. It is:

- a safety larper who OpenAI put up with for a few years when it was part of their brand

- a few "fellows" from some made-up "institutes"

- and an overrated blogger who is super into transhumanist mysticism, not to mention eugenics and race science.

They are hawking a bunch of ideas that would never pass muster in a reputable academic peer-reviewed journal. This is not even JV stuff. They have to make up their own bizarro sphere of foundations and titles to give the appearance of legitimacy. This might fool people who aren't looking closely, but the trick does not work on real academics, nor does it work on the silent majority of those who are actually building the tech capabilities.

And even if you're right, how does this answer my question? I asked you how you know what kridsdale3 believes, and you responded, "Because [you believe this other thing]". Because you believe X, kridsdale can't possibly believe Y.

I sure hope you're just rallying behind the "rationalists" here, and that you don't think of yourself as one, given that you're hazy on the meaning of "because" and you struggle with theory of mind.

Re:AI 2027 by arduanika on Monday April 07, 2025 @04:41PM (#43615730)
I asked you how you know kridsdale3 believes X, and you're reply is basically, "because I believe Y". I hope you don't call yourself a rationalist, given that you're hazy on the meaning of "because" and struggle with theory of mind.

Sure, OpenAI put up with one of these safety larpers for a few years while it was part of their brand. Reasonable people can disagree on how much that counts for.

You're right it's not a bunch of junior academics. It's not even a bunch of junior academics. This stuff would never pass muster in a reputable academic peer-reviewed journal, so from an academic perspective, this is not even the JV stuff. That's why they have to found their own bizarro network of foundations and so on, to give the appearance of seriousness and legitimacy. This might fool people who aren't looking closely, but the trick does not work on real academics, nor does it work on the silent majority of those who are actually building the tech capabilities.

Re:AI 2027 by MrScruff on Friday April 04, 2025 @03:59AM (#43579438)
I kind of agree - since the Bostrom book there is a cottage industry of people with non-technical backgrounds writing papers about singularity thought experiments, and it does seem to be on the spectrum with hard sci-fi writing. A lot of these people are clearly intelligent, and it's not even that I think everything they say is wrong (I made similar assumptions long ago before I'd even heard of Ray Kurzweil and the Singularity, although at the time I would have guessed 2050). It's just that they seem to believe their thought process and Bayesian logic is more rigourous than it actually is.