Re:Show HN: OpenNutrition – A free, public nutrition database
by justsid on Thursday April 03, 2025 @03:31PM
(#43574297)
I find this actually very upsetting. My wife does calorie counting and all of the apps for it are horrible, especially the market leaders. But those have one thing going for them: Databases of nutritional information, which can be used for easy meal calorie counting. Just enter the ingredients (usually you can scan a barcode) and how much you ate of the total and it tells you where you are standing on caloric and nutritional intake. But even those datasets aren’t always bang on, especially here in Canada where some products share bar codes with US products but they have different nutritional values. Reading the title, I was very excited about the ability to make my wife a better app to support her needs. Unfortunately this is not at all usable for this use case or really any? What’s the point of having data that you just can’t trust at all?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Show HN: OpenNutrition – A free, public nutrition database
by joshdickson on Thursday April 03, 2025 @04:00PM
(#43574649)
Why don't you think you can trust the dataset at all? There's a 100+ comment discussion here where we've really only found that perhaps the Australian database's "unsweetened oat milk" (which your wife could log in the app by barcode for an exact product match) doesn't match an expected result.
I use the dataset every day, and when I find something unexpected, it's generally been my own understanding of the food's contents and not a database inaccuracy, although those certainly do exist and I squash them whenever I see a report.