Re:John Cage recital set to last 639 years recently witnesse...
by throwway120385 on Thursday April 03, 2025 @12:36PM
(#43572183)
The experience begins when the conductor starts marking time.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:John Cage recital set to last 639 years recently witnesse...
by jacobgkau on Thursday April 03, 2025 @02:37PM
(#43573642)
There doesn't seem to be a conductor at all in this performance, and there certainly wasn't one for the entire 17 months that the rest lasted. (The person in charge of this project, Rainer Neugebauer, is not conducting; the linked article makes mention of a speech before the note was changed, but nothing about marking time.)
Not that I'd expect a conductor to be needed for a soloist performance, but it makes the whole "when the conductor raises his hands" point a little off-topic.
Re:John Cage recital set to last 639 years recently witnesse...
by bigstrat2003 on Thursday April 03, 2025 @12:45PM
(#43572314)
That's like saying "my meal begins from the time I start driving to the restaurant". It's just not true.
Re:John Cage recital set to last 639 years recently witnesse...
by p_j_w on Thursday April 03, 2025 @01:24PM
(#43572818)
It’s more like saying your meal begins when you sit down at the table, which is a proposition that a lot of people would agree with.
Re:John Cage recital set to last 639 years recently witnesse...
by dontlikeyoueith on Thursday April 03, 2025 @01:58PM
(#43573199)
Certainly every chef-run fine dining restaurant would agree with that.
Re:John Cage recital set to last 639 years recently witnesse...
by dontlikeyoueith on Thursday April 03, 2025 @01:57PM
(#43573192)
It's nothing like that, but you're entitled to be confused and wrong.
Re:John Cage recital set to last 639 years recently witnesse...
by bmacho on Thursday April 03, 2025 @02:21PM
(#43573469)
Technically it's okay to be confused and wrong, but it is not really okay to be vocal about it. It just steals people's time. Maybe it is deliberate trolling, how should we know? Better to be moderated out
Re:John Cage recital set to last 639 years recently witnesse...
by malcolmgreaves on Thursday April 03, 2025 @12:54PM
(#43572423)
Incorrect. A rest is as important to music as a note.