Re:Tell HN: Announcing tomhow as a public moderator
by JoshTriplett on Wednesday April 02, 2025 @04:37PM
(#43561230)
> Personally, I’d prefer no up-/downvoting and flagging at all (or flagging only to alert moderators), and purely chronological threading.
I think that's a very different kind of forum, and it needs different tools to be usable, and it more quickly fails into unusability.
Re:Tell HN: Announcing tomhow as a public moderator
by layer8 on Wednesday April 02, 2025 @04:42PM
(#43561289)
It’s how old-style forums work, and I’m still on a couple of them. It functions quite well with the right moderation.
Re:Tell HN: Announcing tomhow as a public moderator
by JoshTriplett on Wednesday April 02, 2025 @05:47PM
(#43562048)
It can work, but I think it's harder to scale to something the size of HN without losing some of the important properties HN has.
For example, I think it's useful that on balance the top few comments and their discussion are likely to be interesting, and the last few comments are unlikely to be interesting.
Personally, I’d prefer no up-/downvoting and flagging at all (or flagging only to alert moderators), and purely chronological threading. But I also think that active moderation and crowd-sourced ranking mechanics are two different things.