Re:Tell HN: Announcing tomhow as a public moderator
by layer8 on Wednesday April 02, 2025 @02:49PM
(#43560078)
My understanding is that flagging does not imply moderation. When enough people flag a comment, it becomes dead automatically. There is, separately, the case that a moderator “kills” an unacceptable comment, but then it only appears as [dead] I believe (unless it was also being flagged by people). Someone correct me if this is wrong.
Re:Tell HN: Announcing tomhow as a public moderator
by airstrike on Wednesday April 02, 2025 @03:12PM
(#43560382)
Moderation by the community is still moderation.
Re:Tell HN: Announcing tomhow as a public moderator
by layer8 on Wednesday April 02, 2025 @03:34PM
(#43560606)
Well, you can call it that, but there is not a singular will or policy behind what is getting flagged, and the HN “community” isn’t homogeneous. HN users can also “vouch” to counteract flagging. It only takes a single vouch to un-kill a comment.
Re:Tell HN: Announcing tomhow as a public moderator
by ttepasse on Wednesday April 02, 2025 @04:25PM
(#43561097)
The value of "enough" is a moderation decision made by a human.
Re:Tell HN: Announcing tomhow as a public moderator
by layer8 on Wednesday April 02, 2025 @04:37PM
(#43561236)
It’s not a decision made per individual submission or comment, I think. Of course, the specific automated mechanism exists because some human decided to implement it. My point is, in the case of the flagging mechanism, it’s not the moderators who are deciding based on the contents of the submission or comment.
On the other hand, I think it needs to be more specific in order to be valuable feedback. Which dissenting opinions? Can you provide specific examples of comments you think got unreasonably flagged?
There's been an uptick in political posts which are off-topic per the guidelines, so an uptick in the absolute number of flagged submissions would just mean the community is properly enforcing the guidelines, which is good. However, as a consequence of that uptick in political submissions and flagging, there's also an uptick in the number of users complaining a post is unjustly flagged, because they incorrectly conflate enforcing the guidelines with political opinion, and that is not good.
I think a lot of users are tired of this back and forth, so my guess is they are reading between the lines of what you said (since you didn't provide specifics) and filling in the blank with what _they_ think you mean about undeserved flagging, with the topic of politics being top of mind at the moment. This shows that being specific helps both by providing actionable feedback while also increasing clarity, which is your responsibility as a communicator.