Re:Tell HN: Announcing tomhow as a public moderator
by hackyhacky on Wednesday April 02, 2025 @02:29PM
(#43559789)
> My comment itself was barely a criticism of HN
Your comment is (a) off-topic and (b) smacks of a complaint about not getting enough up-votes. Neither of these areas are looked upon positively in HN. If this style of comment is your modus operandi, it may explain why your work is not well-received, and in short it has nothing to do with the popularity of your opinions.
Re:Tell HN: Announcing tomhow as a public moderator
by roflyear on Wednesday April 02, 2025 @11:27PM
(#43564366)
With respect, those are two strawmen.
Re:Tell HN: Announcing tomhow as a public moderator
by hackyhacky on Wednesday April 02, 2025 @11:55PM
(#43564560)
No, I am just describing your comment: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43559544
Re:Tell HN: Announcing tomhow as a public moderator
by roflyear on Thursday April 03, 2025 @09:41AM
(#43569489)
It's not off topic, as it's discussing moderation and the culture of the forum in a post about moderation & replying to someone discussing the culture, and I said nothing about upvotes. It is two strawmen without discussing any of the substance of my comments.
I do think it's OK for some forums - if the community agrees - to say certain topics (like politics) are off limits.
I don't really think it's ok for a community to say discussion about what should be discussed is off limits... or being critical of policies, the bubble, etc...