If you ask 100 random people whether they want to be tracked on line by advertisers, are you really going to tell us that 90% will say yes?
The default of "do not track me please" is 100% correct because it represents the consumers' natural setting.
From the article... "the company said that Windows 8 will inform users of the Do Not Track preference during the first run experience."
They even offer the consumer to make the choice for him/herself.
You present a false dichotomy. In the absence of asking consumers what they actually want in regards to tracking (whatever that means), it is impossible to know what their sentiment is. There are three kinds of people: those who are aware of DNT and have opted in, those who are aware of DNT and have opted out, and those who are not aware of the option. Guess which group is the largest.
You could certainly say that advertisers are intentionally playing dumb here, and would like to continue to do so by forcing the opt-in decision for DNT to be buried in layers of settings dialogs rather than having an opt-out decision front-and-center when installing windows.
But that doesn't imply that anyone thinks most people want to be tracked. It just implies that in the absence of intent one way or the other, advertisers will continue to treat consumers as they always have.
It all comes down to intent. Which is why the whole DNT header is a silly idea in the first place. See qntm's comment below: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4355458.
"How, exactly, are they intending to detect the user's explicit consent via the medium of HTTP headers?"
From the original blog post by MS ... "Since then, we have conducted additional consumer research that confirmed strong support for our "consumer-privacy-first" approach to DNT."
Sounds like that's exactly what they did (asked their users).
> Guess which group is the largest.
The group that you explain what DNT is, and then enables it...
> "How, exactly, are they intending to detect the user's explicit consent via the medium of HTTP headers?"
My understanding is that when shipped (Windows 8 or IE 10), on first run the user is prompted to opt-out of, opt-in, or dismiss DNT. DNT is explained, and is given its own huge screen in the first-run process/dialog.
A set DNT header to 1 (don't track) or 0 (do track) signifies an "explicit" choice was made.
A missing DNT header signifies that user has not set, or has dismissed the option.
http://www.w3.org/2011/tracking-protection/drafts/tracking-d...
http://www.w3.org/QA/2012/04/the_state_of_do_not_track.html
http://blogs.technet.com/b/microsoft_on_the_issues/archive/2...
*I'm taking some guesses here with the "dismiss" choice. But I'm pretty sure MS pulls up a screen explaining DNT and gives the opt-in/out-out options to the user.
Can the W3C justify this amendment at all being for the good of the user?
Here's the working group: http://www.w3.org/2000/09/dbwg/details?group=49311&publi...
I don't know enough to determine what % of companies represented on the panel are ad-supported; per a comment on the Microsoft blog:
> thank you for not folding to the corrupt w3c standards
> body that is setting the standards with a full deck of ad
> supported companies on the panel
http://blogs.technet.com/b/microsoft_on_the_issues/archive/2...(And, given the context of what the group is trying to do -- build a do-not-track mechanism that advertisers are willing to honor -- I agree that it's obvious.)
Although I assumed what all this meant is when you got to that part of the setup the box will be already checked and you had to click on it to turn it off.
Either way, if an attempt to inform the user of the option has been made before they click an "I Agree" button, then that should be good enough.
But honestly, I don't expect many people to honor the DNT header anyway. What's going to happen if they don't, get a strongly worded letter from somebody?
http://www.zdnet.com/microsoft-sticks-to-default-do-not-trac... >Customers will receive prominent notice that their selection of Express Settings turns DNT βon.β
The amendment does not appear to restrict the selection of this option to those who go into settings, click on a privacy tab, and then choose an Advanced settings button, only to have to go through what choosing this means.
They're basically saying, "We're sticking up for consumer privacy! Oh, what? Well we don't want that much privacy - here's an amendment to our proposal so that we can still track you..."
I'm at a loss as to how such an amendment could be in the end user's best interest. How can you even detect such a thing as "the user has actively chosen not to be tracked"? Either the header is there and it means "do not track", or the spec is a joke.
Then, by shoving it in their face like that, your point is invalid and they comply with the spec because the user has chosen not to be tracked, among other things. Now, they would need to force a user to go through that setup as a requirement to use IE10, but that shouldn't be a big issue for MS.
Suppose John Doe sets up a new browser and wants to make sure the DNT header is being sent.
As IE10 sending DNT isn't a response to a conscious user decision ("I accept the defaults" is not consciously deciding "I don't want to be tracked"), servers are basically free to ignore the header if the browser is IE10.
This also means that IE10 will for all intents and purposes always be tracked regardless of what the setting is set to and whether the server in general honors DNT or not (currently I know of only twitter to do so).
Way to go!