http://tos-dr.info/topics.html#cookies
> 5 GitHub requires cookies
5: means it's a low score. So it's considered bad, but it doesn't influence very much the whole class of GitHub.
> GitHub requires cookies to work and misleads you to
> believe that you remain anonymous while cookies contain
> “unique identifiers”. However, only session cookies are
> used, not persistant cookies.
The whole discussion is here https://groups.google.com/d/topic/tosdr/gyMiAkV5ZG0/discussi...
Do you agree/disagree? We welcome contributions!
So yes, I can testify that in this websites case their use of session ids in the url during a website renovation (where people were posting their urls on the forums to help fix bugs) led to a lot of people being made vulnerable.
I just wish they'd at least thanked me for informing them of the vulnerability...
First-Party session cookies are a totally valid use of cookies and actually help improving the security in that a session-id in a cookie will never be copy & pasted by accident (it happens to URL-based session-id's at times) and cookies can be marked as both httponly and secure, making it more difficult to impossible (depending on browser) to XSS the session-id away.
As such I would actually go as far as to prefer a site that requires (first-party session) cookies to one that doesn't.