A-E seems appropriate to me, as an English speaker. For others perhaps not.
A-E is logical I'd say.
Well, apparently it's more complicated than that. I always assumed that the lack of E was so that there would be no confusion with the ESNU system (which a number of students used to have in elementary school, but then they switch over to the A-F system in middle school). Also, many countries outside the U.S., including non-english speaking ones, use the A-F system. Still researching the origin.
I had previously believed that the A-F system was universal across the US college system, though apparently University of Arizona has the 'E' grade.
http://www.jamesaltucher.com/2012/07/how-i-would-unschool-my...
A* to E, and then an actual failure is a U, so as to not just be a continuation from E I assume.
A suggestion - rather than rating "A" through "E" why not change to the more recognizable (for US audience at least) scale of "A through F" (A/B/C/D/F) which we're all mercilessly trained to recognize through years of school grades?
"E" as your worst rating confused me at first glance - could be interpreted as "Excellent"