Re:Wikipedia Redefined
by EvilTerran on Tuesday August 07, 2012 @11:07AM
(#4350412)
That scrollbar also renders the page completely unusable without a mouse. I'm on a notebook here:
- my trackpoint isn't precise enough to move the slider at a reasonable speed;
- there's no click-to-scroll-up/-down buttons, common to pretty much all native scrollbars;
- the up/down arrow keys don't work on that page, either;
- oh, and it's ugly, as well as breaking the user's interface expectations.
Tell me about it. I'm on a MBP and two finger scrolling doesn't work at all for this page.
Also note getting the count of articles by language, in fact all the language tools, require hover. This thing is unusable on tablets or phones.
Re:Wikipedia Redefined
by johnchristopher on Tuesday August 07, 2012 @04:07PM
(#4351991)
What browser ?
I am using latest firefox on latest fedora and I don't see any problems. No fake scrollbars either.
Maybe it has been fixed ?
Re:Wikipedia Redefined
by EvilTerran on Wednesday August 08, 2012 @02:59PM
(#4357390)
Yeah, looks like it's been changed.
There was originally some "arty" looking scroll bar that looked like it was hand-rolled out of images and javascript, and completely failed to have any of the many subtle features that native scrollbars have gained over the years.
Re:Wikipedia Redefined
by EmilStenstrom on Monday August 13, 2012 @01:36PM
(#4377005)
Since they fixed the issue your reported, what are your thoughts on the project they are trying to push?
> Which one would you pick?
Well I'd remove the stupid fucking fake scroll bar from http://www.wikipediaredefined.com for starters. It's horribly unusable on Safari.