Re:I genuinely don't understand why some people are still bu...
by jasonjmcghee on Thursday March 27, 2025 @11:32PM
(#43501239)
> No LLM I have ever used has delivered an expert answer...and that's where all the value is.
If this were true, no one would hire junior employees and assistants. There's a huge amount of work that requires more time than expertise.
LLMs produce midwit answers. If you are an expert in your domain, the results are kind of what you would expect for someone who isn’t an expert. That is occasionally useful but if I wanted a mediocre solution in software I’d use the average library. No LLM I have ever used has delivered an expert answer in software. And that is where all the value is.
I worked in AI for a long time, I like the idea. But LLMs are seemingly incapable of replacing anything of value currently.
The elephant in the room is that there is no training data for the valuable skills. If you have to rely on training data to be useful, LLMs will be of limited use.