Re:Tracing the thoughts of a large language model
by EncomLab on Thursday March 27, 2025 @01:45PM
(#43496006)
This is very interesting - but like all of these discussions it sidesteps the issues of abstractions, compilation, and execution. It's fine to say things like "aren't programmed directly by humans", but the abstracted code is not the program that is running - the compiled code is - and that is code is executing within the tightly bounded constraints of the ISA it is being executed in.
Really this is all so much slight of hand - as an esolang fanatic this all feels very familiar. Most people can't look a program written in Whitespace and figure it out either, but once compiled it is just like every other program as far as the processor is concerned. LLM's are no different.
Re:Tracing the thoughts of a large language model
by ctoth on Thursday March 27, 2025 @02:13PM
(#43496319)
And DNA?
You are running on an instruction set of four symbols at the end of the day but that's the wrong level of abstraction to talk about your humanity, isn't it?
Really this is all so much slight of hand - as an esolang fanatic this all feels very familiar. Most people can't look a program written in Whitespace and figure it out either, but once compiled it is just like every other program as far as the processor is concerned. LLM's are no different.