Re:Ask HN: Is Realtime Interplanetary Communication Feasable?
by pif on Tuesday August 07, 2012 @04:12AM
(#4349194)
> If you asked anyone a hundred years ago if they thought they could have real-time communication with someone half way around they world, they would think you were crazy.
It's a different situation: before the radio was invented, people had no idea ho to communicate that far, but they no reason to believe it was not possible at all: it was just a matter of technology. Regarding talking in real time to Mars, already a century ago they had good reasons to consider it impossible: the scientific knowledge of the world is (and already was a century ago) incompatible with faster-than-light cause-effect relation.
One thing is not to know how to do something, another is knowing it to be impossible, short of stunning scientific discoveries.
It's a different situation: before the radio was invented, people had no idea ho to communicate that far, but they no reason to believe it was not possible at all: it was just a matter of technology. Regarding talking in real time to Mars, already a century ago they had good reasons to consider it impossible: the scientific knowledge of the world is (and already was a century ago) incompatible with faster-than-light cause-effect relation.
One thing is not to know how to do something, another is knowing it to be impossible, short of stunning scientific discoveries.