https://www.wright-brothers.org/History_Wing/History_of_the_...
Not mentioned, though, is Dumont could not turn his airplane. The Wrights could, from the first one.
The only public evidence of anything is their patent application for the control method…which does not prove the veracity of their claims.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wright_Flyer#/media/File:First...
Take a look at the wings - no dihedral. That means it was unstable in roll, and would require constant turning control being applied to keep it from crashing.
> The only public evidence of anything
The Smithsonian has their design notebooks. Also, more than one exacting replica has been made, and they fly and turn.
The witnesses aren’t a particularly credible lot.
The more I looked into the details the more the story looks like a typical startup’s PR campaign. I’m not saying it is Nikola rolling its truck downhill, but the Wrights had similar incentives for a creation myth.
Like I said, I’ve been hearing the story since I was a child. Certainly a Brazilian would be problematic in terms of American exceptionalism and historically prevailing American racial views.
The Smithsonian is an organ of the state and the Wrights notebooks are again self-reported evidence…to put it another way, the Wrights now fill the same institutional role at the Smithsonian in regard to first flight as Langley did at the Smithsonian.
The proof is unusually well documented, and has successfully overcome all kinds of criticism of it.
And these remained in Orville’s hands until after his death in 1949 and mostly the documents from 1903 are attributed to Orville’s hand.
Likewise, the Flyer was restored by Orville for display and money many years later during the period of time when Langley was credited as first. [1]
Finally, the Smithsonian is prohibited from crediting anyone else by the terms of sale for its purchase of Orville’s restoration. [2]
Basically, we have Orville’s word for everything and a contract that contractually incentivizes the Smithsonian to take it as gospel.
Again, thanks for inspiring me to go beyond the national myth and look at the Wrights critically.
[1] https://www.loc.gov/collections/wilbur-and-orville-wright-pa...
[2] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wright_Flyer#After_Kitty_Haw...
There is no sense in which he was a pretender. He had been “open source” flying for years.