News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Wright brothers invented the airplane, right? Not if ... by WalterBright on Monday March 24, 2025 @09:53PM (#43467383)
The Wrights' achievement is powered, controlled flight.
Re:The Wright brothers invented the airplane, right? Not if ... by crazygringo on Monday March 24, 2025 @10:33PM (#43467613)
You're helping my point.

Define powered. Powered enough to take off from a flat surface without wind? Could the Flyer III do that? Or are you allowed to have wind behind you? If so, how much? Surely not 50 knots? Where's the line?

Define controlled. Look at how much Flyer I and Flyer II crashed. Are they controlled? How controlled is controlled? Where's the line?

I'm not saying who invented the plane. I'm saying reasonable people will come up with different reasonable definitions. Different totally justifiable lines. And it's not "denialism" to appreciate that reality.

Re:The Wright brothers invented the airplane, right? Not if ... by WalterBright on Tuesday March 25, 2025 @03:52AM (#43468883)
See this article:

https://www.wright-brothers.org/History_Wing/History_of_the_...

It covers your points, except it doesn't mention 3-axis control that the Wrights had in their first Flyer, and the Europeans did not have until the Wrights demonstrated flying in circles.

Yes, the Flyer III could and did take off and fly without wind or catapult.

Controlled means 3 axis control. The Flyer had all the critical elements of an airplane in place.

Re:The Wright brothers invented the airplane, right? Not if ... by crazygringo on Tuesday March 25, 2025 @08:45AM (#43470521)
You seem to be misunderstanding again. You are arbitrarily defining these things. Based on what? And why is your definition more valid than someone else's?

And per your own link, the earlier Flyers did not take off without wind:

> They also ignore the records of the flights the Wrights made in 1904 and 1905, which show that the catapult wasn't always used. If the Wrights felt they had sufficient headwinds, they took off without it.

It's not clear from the article when the first time was that it took off without catapult or wind. It seems to suggest 1908?

But the larger point is that you're taking the definition of flight for granted as whatever you've defined it to be. You don't seem to be acknowledging that other people can validly disagree, and that that's OK.

Re:The Wright brothers invented the airplane, right? Not if ... by WalterBright on Tuesday March 25, 2025 @06:53PM (#43476931)
I actually have a degree in Aeronautical Engineering. I'm quite comfortable with the definition of powered, controlled flight. It's not arbitrary.

The thing is, nobody else even came close to the Wright's achievement for years afterwards. No amount of cooking the definition of controlled, powered flight is going to fix that for a pretender.

Re:The Wright brothers invented the airplane, right? Not if ... by crazygringo on Wednesday March 26, 2025 @11:56AM (#43483592)
You continue to miss the point entirely.

This isn't about aeronautical engineering. It's not about your definitions. It's not about your degree. It's not about what came afterwards.

This is about semantic definition, and how definitions of thresholds are arbitrary to a large degree, and why it's valid to differ.

Your refusal to acknowledge that another point of view might have its own validity says a lot. But the world is a larger place than just your perspective. And that's something that has consequences far beyond anything to do with who invented the first airplane.

Re:The Wright brothers invented the airplane, right? Not if ... by WalterBright on Wednesday March 26, 2025 @09:57PM (#43489674)
The consequences are that all modern aircraft can trace their lineage back to the Wright Flyer, not to any of the other contenders.
Re:The Wright brothers invented the airplane, right? Not if ... by crazygringo on Sunday April 06, 2025 @09:00AM (#43601140)
The definition of being first, and the definition of what modern versions are derived from, are two totally different things.

The latter has no bearing whatsoever on the former. It's very interesting in its own right, but it's completely different.

Re:The Wright brothers invented the airplane, right? Not if ... by lupusreal on Tuesday March 25, 2025 @02:07PM (#43474127)
Saying that its not an airplane because the Wrights took off into headwinds is peak retardation. All pilots do so whenever possible. Aircraft carriers deliberately create their own headwinds whenever possible. The Wrights were so far ahead of everybody else there is no reasonable room to quibble and when they finally got around to going to Europe, the Frenchmen who were previously skeptics of the Wrights said as much.
Re:The Wright brothers invented the airplane, right? Not if ... by lupusreal on Tuesday March 25, 2025 @03:32PM (#43474952)
Crazygringo, I'm sorry I called you retarded, that wasn't justified and I need to do better.

"Sputnik wasn't the first satellite because it went prograde, taking advantage of the Earth's rotation."

"Gragarin wasn't the first man in orbit because he didn't get out of his capsule."

"Laika wasn't the first dog in space because she died."

Even the most shamelessly jingoistic American baby boomers I've ever met have too much shame to try anything like these, but this is what you sound like. Absolutely retarded.