Re:Show HN: My iOS app to practice sight reading (10 years i...
by spunker540 on Sunday March 23, 2025 @06:45PM
(#43456506)
This may sound crazy but my sight reading improved a lot after I took an ear training class that required me to work in arbitrary clefs. I always knew treble and bass from playing piano, and had really memorized the note positions in each.
When I was suddenly forced to work in tenor, alto, soprano, baritone clefs, I could no longer rely on memorization of note positions. I had to pivot to “reading intervals”. A fifth looks the same in any clef, so if you know the current note, and the next note is a fifth above, you know the next note too, clef be damned.
Re:Show HN: My iOS app to practice sight reading (10 years i...
by thaumasiotes on Monday March 24, 2025 @04:16AM
(#43458553)
> A fifth looks the same in any clef
Really? I don't think all fifths look the same even if they're all in the same clef. If you're working in C major, B to F looks like it's a fifth, but it's a tritone.
Random clefs seem like they would make that problem worse.
Re:Show HN: My iOS app to practice sight reading (10 years i...
by whiddershins on Sunday March 23, 2025 @10:22PM
(#43457401)
In my experience, accidentally memorizing what you are reading doesn't really get in the way of what most people think of as sight reading. Internalizing structures and patterns is 99% of what it means ti "learn to read."
That's what comes from playing simpler rock stuff by ear/memory for many years and then moving to large amounts of material which can't be done only by ear.
My solution is to have a large amount of unfamiliar material and just open to a random page and start working things out.