News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Joel Spolsky: Thanks or No Thanks by kscaldef on Wednesday January 14, 2009 @05:19PM (#434429)
Yahoo got too dependent on their "super-secret" retention bonuses. The first couple times they did it, it made you feel special. But, eventually it became clear that it was just a way to avoid giving raises and promotions. Maybe you haven't hit that point, but trust me, lots of us got demotivated by it.
Re:Joel Spolsky: Thanks or No Thanks by IsaacSchlueter on Thursday January 15, 2009 @03:47AM (#434992)
You're claiming that "secret" retention bonuses are a way to avoid "giving" promotions and raises? Wow, there's a lot wrong with both parts of that statement.

Almost every company encourages their employees to never disclose their pay to their coworkers. It promotes an information imbalance where the employer wins. Unless you sign something saying that you won't disclose it (which would probably be contestable anyhow), or you're sharing it with someone who doesn't want to know (which would just be rude and potentially disruptive), they can't fire you for telling people what you make.

Don't do it, plain and simple. If you didn't agree to keep it a secret, then it's not a secret. With all of my raises and bonuses-that-not-everyone-gets, I was discrete, just as my bosses asked of me. I only share my compensation information with anyone and everyone who wants to know. It's time we changed this stupid "secret salary" custom.

Also, promotions and raises aren't given, they're taken. You're a grownup, why should your employer care more about your career than you do? Want a promotion? Take more responsibility. Be more essential. Be a leader. Want a raise? Get a better offer, and ask your employer to match it. Write essays, share code, increase your skillset, help your juniors, always be finding ways to make the product better, ways to make the team's processes more efficient.

If you just want to do your job and stay warm, that's fine, but don't expect to get special treatment. A yearly 2-7% cost-of-living pay increase is probably about right.

It sounds harsh, I know, and I'm sure this might not have been your angle at all. I just get annoyed hearing about employees who dutifully do no more than they're told, and wait and hope for review time as if it's christmas, and then get upset when they're treated like cogs in a machine, when they've been acting exactly like cogs in a machine.

Re:Joel Spolsky: Thanks or No Thanks by anewaccountname on Thursday January 15, 2009 @08:29PM (#436026)
>they can't fire you for telling people what you make.

Yes they can. Unless you are talking about Western Europe or something.

Re:Joel Spolsky: Thanks or No Thanks by IsaacSchlueter on Sunday January 18, 2009 @04:46PM (#439728)
I'm talking about the US.

To be clear, in California at least, you can be fired or quit for any or no reason whatsoever. So, yes, to correct what I said, an employer could fire you for sharing your salary, or for the car you drive, or for the color of your hair, or just because they don't like you for no specific reason. (But not for your gender, race, disabilities, or religion. Doesn't that seem odd?)

However, very few employers will fire you for this. And, if they're that serious about keeping their employees in a disadvantageous position, maybe you ought to find a more respectful employer.

Re:Joel Spolsky: Thanks or No Thanks by ph0rque on Thursday January 15, 2009 @08:31PM (#436030)
>I only share my compensation information with anyone and everyone who wants to know.

So, how much do you make? ;~)

Re:Joel Spolsky: Thanks or No Thanks by IsaacSchlueter on Sunday January 18, 2009 @04:26PM (#439698)
Sent to your email address. (I don't share that kind of thing on message boards, because some people don't want to know.)
Re:Joel Spolsky: Thanks or No Thanks by ph0rque on Sunday January 18, 2009 @04:31PM (#439706)
My post was tongue-in-cheek... thanks anyway, though!
Re:Joel Spolsky: Thanks or No Thanks by IsaacSchlueter on Thursday January 15, 2009 @12:13PM (#435333)
Clarification: when I said "Don't do it," I meant, "Don't keep it a secret."

Sorry, that was kind of awkwardly phrased. Should have reread before posting.