Re:The Pain That Is GitHub Actions
by crabbone on Thursday March 20, 2025 @06:15AM
(#43421388)
YAML's problems:
* Very easy to write the code you didn't mean to, especially in the context of CI where potentially a lot of languages are going to be mixed, a lot of quoting and escaping. YAML's string literals are a nightmare.
* YAML has no way to express inheritance. Nor does it have a good way to express variables. Both are usually desperately needed in CI scripts, and are usually bolted on top with some extra-language syntax (all those dollars in GitHub actions, Helm charts, Ansible playbooks etc.)
* Complexity skyrockets compared to the size of the file. I.e. in a language like C you can write a manageable program with millions of lines of code. In YAML you will give up after a few tens of thousands of lines (similar to SQL or any other language that doesn't have modules).
* Whitespace errors are very hard to spot and fix. Often whitespace errors in YAML result in valid YAML which, however, doesn't do what you want...
* Very easy to write the code you didn't mean to, especially in the context of CI where potentially a lot of languages are going to be mixed, a lot of quoting and escaping. YAML's string literals are a nightmare.
* YAML has no way to express inheritance. Nor does it have a good way to express variables. Both are usually desperately needed in CI scripts, and are usually bolted on top with some extra-language syntax (all those dollars in GitHub actions, Helm charts, Ansible playbooks etc.)
* Complexity skyrockets compared to the size of the file. I.e. in a language like C you can write a manageable program with millions of lines of code. In YAML you will give up after a few tens of thousands of lines (similar to SQL or any other language that doesn't have modules).
* Whitespace errors are very hard to spot and fix. Often whitespace errors in YAML result in valid YAML which, however, doesn't do what you want...