Re:For Many of America's Aging Workers, 'Retirement Is a Dis...
by Jtsummers on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @05:13PM
(#43417380)
You're using the term "progressive tax" to talk about the benefit or return, which is not what it actually means.
Progressive, flat, and regressive taxes are not about how the money gets used or redistributed. It's a simple thing: Is the tax rate constant across all incomes? Flat. Does the tax rate increase as income increases? Progressive. Does the tax rate decrease as income increases? Regressive.
OASDI is a regressive tax. Flat for the first $176k, then drops after that.
Re:For Many of America's Aging Workers, 'Retirement Is a Dis...
by Kirby64 on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @05:19PM
(#43417433)
And you're using far too strict of a definition of tax. Think of it another way: if I make $1, and the government takes $0.10, but then gives me back $0.05 later, but my rich neighbor who makes $10 the government takes $1 and he only gets back $0.10 later... how is my neighbor not taxed more (effectively) than me?
For example (a few scenarios I ran here) with a “full retirement age” set to 2035 (when you’d be 67)
If you earned a constant wage of $50k/yr, you would be able to draw $2044/mo in SS. Tax per year would be 6.2%, or $3100/yr.
If you earned a constant wage of $150k/yr, you would be able to draw $3843/mo. Tax per year would be $9300/yr.
You receive about 88% more benefits but contribute 300% more money. How is that not progressive taxation?