News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Solar Generation Surge Sends European Power Prices Below ... by pjc50 on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @01:03PM (#43414562)
The UK decided to build a nuclear power station as well in 2010: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hinkley_Point_C_nuclear_power_...

It is still not operational. Nuclear is too slow. As well as not especially cheap either.

There's also a lot of market stupidity in the UK: the marginal price for the most expensive generation sets the price for all generation. In some cases this results in weird situations like wind farms paying back the government because the electricity price was too high for their CFD.

Re:Solar Generation Surge Sends European Power Prices Below ... by johngladtj on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @01:09PM (#43414641)
Nuclear is not too slow, bureaucracy and political ill will is.

How many nuclear power plants has china built during a similar period? How many did France when they were building out their grid?

This isn't a technical problem.

Re:Solar Generation Surge Sends European Power Prices Below ... by ViewTrick1002 on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @01:23PM (#43414824)
France is currently wholly unable to build new nuclear power.

Their latest plant is 7x over budget and 13 years late on a 5 year construction schedule.

The EPR2 program is continuously being delayed, with the most recent news being a absolutely massive subsidy program and hopefully final investment decision in mid 2026. With the current target date being the first reactor finished by 2038.

China is also massively scaling back their nuclear power ambitions. Since 2020 they have been averaging 4-5 construction starts a year leading to something like a 3% nuclear share of the grid at saturation.

Compare with 15 years ago when they were targeting a French like 70%.

Re:Solar Generation Surge Sends European Power Prices Below ... by rstuart4133 on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @06:50PM (#43418070)
> How many nuclear power plants has china built during a similar period?

About 1/40th of the amount of renewables they built in the same period.

Re:Solar Generation Surge Sends European Power Prices Below ... by cyberax on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @01:09PM (#43414638)
Nuclear power plants can be built much faster. 6 years from the first concrete to completion is possible.

The key is to not design each reactor as a unique snowflake.

Re:Solar Generation Surge Sends European Power Prices Below ... by loeg on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @01:23PM (#43414820)
Churn out more nothing-special AP1000s.
Re:Solar Generation Surge Sends European Power Prices Below ... by pjc50 on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @04:12PM (#43416743)
How many of these have been built?
Re:Solar Generation Surge Sends European Power Prices Below ... by cyberax on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @04:21PM (#43416841)
Twelve AP1000s are in operation or are in the final construction steps. 20 more are in the planning stages.

Russia's Rosatomexport is building roughly similar VVER-1200 power plants within about ~6 years from the first concrete. E.g.: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rooppur_Nuclear_Power_Plant

They are indeed "nothing special" plants.

Re:Solar Generation Surge Sends European Power Prices Below ... by loeg on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @05:39PM (#43417601)
Also the Chinese CAP1000 design is largely just an AP1000, and China plans to go from shovels down to operation in five years: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lianjiang_Nuclear_Power_Plant
Re:Solar Generation Surge Sends European Power Prices Below ... by ximus on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @01:09PM (#43414642)
Hinkley Point is the premier example of how badly slow a nuclear development can be. Reactors are often built in 5-7 years.
Re:Solar Generation Surge Sends European Power Prices Below ... by myrmidon on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @01:38PM (#43415029)
Vogtle 3/4 (USA): 10 years.

Shin-Hanul (Korea): 12 years.

Olkiluoto (Finland): 18 years.

Flamanville (France): 17 years.

I did not even need to cherry pick those. Your estimates are wildly unrealistic.

Also note: Those times are from begin of construction, not start of planning (!!).

Re:Solar Generation Surge Sends European Power Prices Below ... by epistasis on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @01:50PM (#43415204)
This sort of numerical deception is endemic in nuclear advocacy dicsussions. I don't know if it's intentional, the best explanation I have is that somebody proposes an (unrealistic) number as a goal, and then it's accepted by advocates as the reality. But if reality was known, the person probably would not be an advocate.

I have not yet met an advocate that will talk about the real, existing, challenges to nuclear the same way that renewable energy advocates talk about the challenges. Go and listen to a podcast on renewables, and it's all about what's not working, what's working, where the opportunities are, and what needs to be changed with the tech. Go listen to a nuclear energy podcast and all you get is wishful thinking, rose-colored glasses, and papering over the real problems that face the real projects.

Edit: for example of the podcasts, here's Jigar Shah on Decouple https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HwN1MCtBkVk giving the hosts a dose of reality. And Shah is far more optimistic than nearly any realistic person on nuclear, the Liftoff plan (https://liftoff.energy.gov/advanced-nuclear-2/) that his department produced starts from an unrealistic current position and then assumes massive gains somehow to get to a competitive position. It's rose-colored glasses in itself, but at least it shows a plan of how to make nuclear realistic.

Re:Solar Generation Surge Sends European Power Prices Below ... by loeg on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @05:53PM (#43417687)
This is a pretty bad faith comment.

There are lots of wind and solar advocates completely glossing over the difference between nameplate generation capacity (maximum capacity) and intermittency and the value of an intermittent source in the market (marginal rate payment schemes vastly overvalue intermittent sources). That doesn't make it ok for nuclear advocates to do the same, but your portrayal of nuclear advocates as uniquely biased is inaccurate.

I agree with you that Jigar Shah knows what he's talking about and is worth listening to, but disagree that he is some magical thinker wishful optimist about nuclear in particular. He would say that basically, by the time you include the cost of additional gas generation (which is like, fully supply-chain constrained through 2030+) and battery storage, everything costs more than $100/MWh and nuclear looks competitive, even at Vogtle 3/4 prices and especially with some experience curve effects.

Re:Solar Generation Surge Sends European Power Prices Below ... by ViewTrick1002 on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @07:05PM (#43418169)
Now add that nuclear power has famously had a negative learning curve. It doesn’t even take the latest boondoggles into account.

https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S03014...

At the same time storage is absolutely plummeting in price with the latest auctions in China landing on $63/kWh serviced for 20 years.

Then we have comprehensive grid modeling:

See the recent study on Denmark which found that nuclear power needs to come down 85% in cost to be competitive with renewables when looking into total system costs for a fully decarbonized grid, due to both options requiring flexibility to meet the grid load.

> Focusing on the case of Denmark, this article investigates a future fully sector-coupled energy system in a carbon-neutral society and compares the operation and costs of renewables and nuclear-based energy systems.

> The study finds that investments in flexibility in the electricity supply are needed in both systems due to the constant production pattern of nuclear and the variability of renewable energy sources.

> However, the scenario with high nuclear implementation is 1.2 billion EUR more expensive annually compared to a scenario only based on renewables, with all systems completely balancing supply and demand across all energy sectors in every hour.

> For nuclear power to be cost competitive with renewables an investment cost of 1.55 MEUR/MW must be achieved, which is substantially below any cost projection for nuclear power.

https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S030626192...

Or the same for Australia if you went a more sunny locale finding that renewables ends up with a grid costing less than half of "best case nth of a kind nuclear power":

https://www.csiro.au/-/media/Energy/GenCost/GenCost2024-25Co...

Re:Solar Generation Surge Sends European Power Prices Below ... by myrmidon on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @08:34PM (#43418774)
My personal theory is that a lot of nuclear advocates are pro-nuclear first (possibly to be contrarian, or because they think the tech is cool), then look for favorable facts/data second.

Meaning the advocacy is not driven by best-effort current estimates of efficiency/cost/benefits-- its the other way around, leading to such a high number of overoptimistic takes on it.

Re:Solar Generation Surge Sends European Power Prices Below ... by loeg on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @05:45PM (#43417636)
Pretty much all of the dozens (56!) of reactors France built in the 70s took 5-6 years between construction and operation. How much weight do you give those dozens of builds, vs a couple one-offs? Yes, the fact that we've waited 40 years to build another single reactor is part of the problem. But it gets faster if you don't do crazy one-off designs and you get some experience building more than, you know, one.
Re:Solar Generation Surge Sends European Power Prices Below ... by myrmidon on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @08:22PM (#43418707)
If your hypothesis was true (cost overruns and delays are caused by lack of recent build experience in every western nation, and would immediately vanish if we started building more reactors) then we would expect to see the same clear trend of decreasing build time with experience in the past.

But in fact early reactors (e.g. Marcoule, or Tricastin) got built faster than the later ones (=> possibly because Chernobyl happened, and everyone reevaluated risk). So that hypothesis is clearly wrong.

And even if build times of under a decade were a realistic target for US/Europe (which I see no indication for)-- how many plants would we need to build first to hit those improvements, in your opinion? If we needed just a single full planning/construction iteration, then we could expect those miraculous 5-year-on-budget-reactors to come online in like 2050. Thats basically the best case scenario (!!). Might as well wait for fusion reactors then (that was sarcasm; fusion reactors are gonna be irrelevant in fighting climate change for exactly the same reasons; too much complexity, too expensive, too slow).

Re:Solar Generation Surge Sends European Power Prices Below ... by loeg on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @08:38PM (#43418795)
Vogtle actual costs are already competitive with actual renewables costs, and build times are vastly better than the 25 year timeline you're calling a "best case scenario" here.
Re:Solar Generation Surge Sends European Power Prices Below ... by myrmidon on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @09:32PM (#43419113)
> Vogtle actual costs are already competitive with actual renewables costs

No. At $160/MWh? Maybe competitive with renewable costs 15 years ago. Most certainly not with renewable cost now (and those still trend down).

> build times are vastly better than the 25 year timeline you're calling a "best case scenario" here

That timeline is for finishing one plant at currently speed, and then planning and finishing a ton of new reactors within 5 year buildtimes directly after. But I see zero confidence that this is actually realistic, not even from the the companies that just finished building Vogtle...

Re:Solar Generation Surge Sends European Power Prices Below ... by loeg on Thursday March 20, 2025 @12:34PM (#43425454)
Fully loaded renewable costs (with sufficient storage or gas generation to achieve firm production) is over $100/MWh, yes.
Re:Solar Generation Surge Sends European Power Prices Below ... by philjohn on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @01:27PM (#43414898)
And also the ruinous planning regulations in the UK, which thankfully the current Labour government have signalled they're going to reform (which hopefully means gutting a lot of them).
Re:Solar Generation Surge Sends European Power Prices Below ... by ViewTrick1002 on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @01:24PM (#43414846)
Which modern western reactor was built in 5-7 years?

It feels quite strange to base our data on half a century old data because you don’t like the recent data experience.

Re:Solar Generation Surge Sends European Power Prices Below ... by ZeroGravitas on Thursday March 20, 2025 @05:52AM (#43421278)
There is some market (and regulatory) stupidity but both your cited ones have reasonable cases to be made for them.

If you order the bids low to high then pay the highest bid then a) you encourage honest (i.e. lower) priced bids and drive expensive/inefficient plants out the market while encouraging new low price entrants who can guarantee they'll get used (because low bid) and make money, driving the market price lower.

The problem is the expensive gas caused by Russian invasions and planning a market pricing mechanism around such events is kind of silly when you can just windfall tax to fix the problem quickly and easily if the energy companies aren't all run by your mates from private school.

But also generation ain't the whole cost, there's the grid fees and taxes. The latter made sense when burning coal and now are looking likely to be shifted to gas.

Collar prices on wind farms are actually a genius bit of financial engineering, guaranteeing minimum funding in a volatile market at low cost by capping the profits.