News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:US appeals court rules AI generated art cannot be copyrig... by soerxpso on Tuesday March 18, 2025 @06:31PM (#43405953)
In the case mentioned above where someone just spins around in their chair and takes a random photo on their phone (which they would then own the rights to), did that person really do any 'creative input'? All they did was press a button on a tool, with no further thought. That actually seems like less creative input than when I type a prompt into a tool and hit 'generate'. Why are cameras, image editors, etc, tools in a way that stable diffusion is not?
Re:US appeals court rules AI generated art cannot be copyrig... by Aloisius on Tuesday March 18, 2025 @06:49PM (#43406110)
If you can show that no human creative expression was involved in composition, timing, etc, then no, it's not copyrightable.

There's a very good argument for security camera footage not being copyrightable for that very reason. There just hasn't been any case law yet to test it.

Re:US appeals court rules AI generated art cannot be copyrig... by Retric on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @10:41AM (#43412647)
There are cases like taking a drivers license photo that actually lack sufficient creativity to generate copyrighted content. Assign random values to every pixel in an image so anything count result and you don’t have creative input and thus presumably zero copyright.

With AI images you didn’t setup the training data, so it’s like asking someone else to take a photo of something that makes them think of ducks. Different training data would produce wildly different outcomes. Like the DMV photo you didn’t add enough creative input to count.