> It is intended
What evidence do you have of the GP's intent? Or of all the other people who say the same?
Your question is answered here in fair depth: https://www.ajc.org/sites/default/files/pdf/2021-10/A%20Guid...
On top of that a few tests we can apply:
- Are Jewish people judged to a different standard than others?
- Is the pattern similar to historical persecution of the Jewish people, specifically in this case we're talking about blood libels: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blood_libel
- Follow the money or literally find the source of the accusation. Is the source clearly antisemitic? Then the accusation is likely antisemitic.
Let's say you are or might be a serial killer. How should I talk about it without offending you? Just asking.
If for example Israel was setting up gas chambers and systemically killing all the Palestinians in the middle east that would be pretty hard to hide. If you have no evidence you're going to go down the road of interpreting the genocide convention to fit your agenda, misrepresenting the ICC ( https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bq9MB9t7WlI ), making up things, cherry-picking statements by Israeli officials and ignoring ones that don't suit your agenda. etc. The simplest explanation here that holds water is that we have a war during which we have civilians casualties.
If that is an issue, it absolutely should be addressed; personal offense doesn't outweigh the deaths of others. Imagine if an alleged serial killer said, 'nobody can talk about that because it offends me.'
It's also a well-worn tactic to change the subject from one's own behavior to attacking people who raise the issue - the right-wing has been using it for years, now on behalf of Israel.
I'm not changing the subject: The issue is that Israel has killed ~50,000 people, injured many more, and destroyed most of their resources including things like healthcare, infrastructure, just buildings. It is blocking access to food and essential supplies. Palestinians in the West Bank are subject to have their property stolen, physical violence, lack of the rule of law, and being terrorized. Israeli leaders openly talk about seizing Palestinian territory, harming Palestinians, and contempt for harming them.
Whatever you call it, those are the issues. Whether it meets a legal standard of genocide is something a court can figure out, but there are warrants from a widely-recognized court.
The number of casualties is consistent with the kind of war that's being waged. If Hamas hadn't used healthcare and educational facilities then those wouldn't be targeted.
The warrants are not related to genocide. They're about war crimes. They're also political and illegal (Israel isn't a member of the ICC and Palestine is not a country) but there you went and changed the subject again.
Israel can kill as many people it takes to secure its citizens. As long as it is targeting Hamas, which it is, there is no upper bound. It can legally target hospitals and schools that are used by Hamas. That is all legal and moral. The rest is up to the Palestinians and Hamas. If Hamas removes the need for Israel to keep fighting it by surrendering then this war will be over. If Hamas keeps threatening to kill Israelis then Israel will eliminate this threat just like any other country would.
A by the way is that this practice of using schools, hospitals, and mosques, e.g. isn't unique to Hamas, if you check this article: https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/cjw4egp7lwno
You'll see Hezbollah has also set up headquarters in schools in Syria.
Another subject again- Palestinians in/from the west bank are killing civilians and attacking Israelis. That is the root cause for what's going on there. Once they stop doing that we can make progress. The Israeli right is in power because Palestinian violence has convinced Israelis the only way that they can live in peace is to put a right wing government who will be extremely harsh with the Palestinians in power. This is the Palestinians own doing as a group. Sure, I sympathize at the individual level but as a group they decide to take a path of violence against a much stronger group and do their best to create a situation in which they are going to lose a lot.
Palestinians need to drop their violent struggle and the gullible people of the west need to stop supporting that. That is the only way they will get anything. We were on that path to some extent during the Oslo accords and the Palestinians literally blew this up, along with hundres of Israelis in busses and malls and restaurants.
My language was intentional and precise. I didn't say "colonialism" (which I'm not defending BTW). I said "settler colonialism" [1], which is precisely what has gone on here. From the Nakba to the 1967 war to the West Bank settlers, you have over 75 years of ethnic cleansing and displacement. That's ettler colonialism.
I can't speak to whatever colonial society you're from. You don't say. I will say I struggle to think of examples of where colonialism worked out well for the colonized however.
Honest question, not trolling. I assume that you see the situation differently, I'd love to understand your viewpoint if you care to explain it.
In the roughly 20 years of the US military action in Vietnam, 63 journalists were killed or otherwise assume killed (as they were missing) [3]. There have been at least 170 journalists who have been killed in Gaza since October 7 [4]. This continues a decades-long campaign of Israeli targeted assassintion of journalists such as Shireen Abu-Akleh [5], who despite wearing a blue press helmet and vest was killed by a single sniper shot behind her ear.
And how does our government respond? By passing laws saying that the criticism of Zionism (being setter colonialism) is inherently anti-Semitic, the so-called IHRA definition [6].
My point here is the US law enforcement exists to protect the interests of capital and those who own it. The FBI used to wiretap and surveil MLLK, for example.
All of this, including the LAPS monitoring social media, is intended to silence dissent. The clearly illegal attempted deportation of Mahmoud Khalil without being charged let alone convicted, is a clear First Amendment violation.
[1]: https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2025/feb/11/gaza-protest...
[2]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_cases_of_the_January_6...
[3]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_journalists_killed_and...
[4]: https://cpj.org/2025/02/journalist-casualties-in-the-israel-...
[5]: https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2023/10/16/israeli-forces-kil...
[6]: https://www.theguardian.com/news/2020/nov/29/palestinian-rig...