Neither the Will nor the Cash: Why India Wins So Few Olympic Medals

Re:Neither the Will nor the Cash: Why India Wins So Few Olym... by _debug_ on Saturday August 04, 2012 @10:29AM (#4338536)

IMHO, with a billion people, I believe that BOTH a) your generalization is true, i.e., the majority is disinterested AND b) not relevant w.r.t. Olympic medal-winning potential : it is enough for a small minority to be interested in sport / fitness & glory to make the cut for the olympics. I believe that the 80/20 rule applies, and is actually more of a 95/5 rule in most societies and most achievements : 5% of the population account for the glory (, the rest just wake the flag and feel proud, conveniently forgetting that one cannot be proud of what one did not achieve personally).

I suspect you might find a similar proportion of everday Chinese equally disinterested in "poses" (not sure, just speculation).

I believe that the core reason is our usual friend, corruption and red tape. It's not just sports; in general, the meritocratic lose out because wherever there is an opportunity in India, whatever be the form of opportunity. That includes what is rightfully yours, such as welfare handouts, your passport, etc; An Indian's everyday life consists of jumping through hoops to get basic things done.

Disclaimer : am Indian.

[ Parent | on HN ]

Re:Neither the Will nor the Cash: Why India Wins So Few Olym... by yummyfajitas on Saturday August 04, 2012 @11:13AM (#4338652)

There certainly is some 95/5 rule, or probably a 999/1 rule. But you need to apply the 999/1 rule to the people actually interested in going for the gold. I.e., in the US that might be 0.001 x 25% whereas in India it might be closer to 0.001 x 5%.

My issue with theories like corruption/red tape/etc is that India is not unique in this regard. India is pretty bad with corruption, but Jamaica is too. Yet Jamaica tends to perform pretty well - running is popular there. You can find plenty of corrupt and poor countries that outperform India, particularly if you adjust for population.

China is a special case since the government basically forces people to shoot for Olympic gold in marginal sports (e.g., discus, javelin) and trains them from early ages to do so. They also use eugenics to breed top athletes (Yao Ming is one famous result of this), and similar things.

[ Parent | on HN ]

Re:Neither the Will nor the Cash: Why India Wins So Few Olym... by w1ntermute on Saturday August 04, 2012 @12:44PM (#4338900)

> China is a special case since the government basically forces people to shoot for Olympic gold in marginal sports

This is a common misconception. No one is "forced" to participate in the Olympics in China. Poor parents send their children to Olympic trainers because if their children do well, they'll get to go to college for free and have a good, middle-class job.

[ Parent | on HN ]

Re:Neither the Will nor the Cash: Why India Wins So Few Olym... by _debug_ on Sunday August 05, 2012 @12:28PM (#4341830)

Good point about Jamaica. I'll have to throw my theory out of the window for now!

[ Parent | on HN ]