News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by matthewdgreen on Sunday March 16, 2025 @07:32PM (#43383640)
Tear gas and more lethal gasses were extensively used in WWI. Afterwards the various belligerents came to an agreement on which weapons were acceptable, and they specifically decided to include tear gas in that ban. There were various reasons they did this (fear of escalation to lethal gasses was the biggest concern) but one specific reason was the indiscriminate nature of the gas as well as the fact that it can cause unnecessary suffering. It is true that the Geneva Convention only bans tear gas for warfare, and allowed it for military riot control. The CWC then banned it even for those military applications in the 1990s. Some of the arguments made against the use of tear gas in military applications (in the 1920s and 1990s) also make good arguments for minimizing or eliminating its use in law enforcement settings.

Rationalists like to reduce everything to a simple black and white argument, which tends to inject imprecision and bad understanding into the discourse.

Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by gruez on Sunday March 16, 2025 @07:39PM (#43383688)
>one specific reason was the indiscriminate nature of the gas

What are you talking about? The canisters launched by police are probably as discriminate as you can be when firing into a crowd. Are you expecting some sort of weapon that can precisely target the rioters in a crowd but leave everyone alone?

>as well as the fact that it can cause unnecessary suffering.

In the sense that "tear gas is just mustard gas", or "protesters have every right to be there and therefore any sort of discomfort is 'unnecessary suffering'"? What amount of "suffering" would you find acceptable?

Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by fc417fc802 on Sunday March 16, 2025 @08:27PM (#43383959)
I largely agree with what you wrote.

> Rationalists like to ...

But then you tacked this on to the end and it's entirely unnecessary. The linked article is actually a very good one about recognizing bad faith use of labels.

It just doesn't really apply in this case because the original point (at least by my reading) wasn't a gotcha relying on the definition of a label but rather was using a label that the author believes is legitimate to point out the seeming inconsistency.

Of course whether or not the label is legitimate is itself perfectly reasonable to discuss.

Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by matthewdgreen on Monday March 17, 2025 @01:14PM (#43390643)
My problem with the linked argument -- and specifically, with the idea of linking it and not so much the argument -- is that it takes a statement with validity and then tries to use a kind of rhetorical trick to argue that it's false. It is not false, which is the entire point of my post, and those rhetorical cookbook tricks harm understanding and lead us away from truth, because the world is full of nuance and complexity.
Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by axus on Sunday March 16, 2025 @07:25PM (#43383585)
Or "murder is wrong, because God said so"
Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by mandmandam on Sunday March 16, 2025 @07:41PM (#43383701)
This isn't a case of a noncentral fallacy.

> "Tear gas is bad because it violates the Geneva convention" makes as much sense as "MLK is a bad person because he's a criminal".

Not really, no. The Geneva Convention has specific reasoning and rationale for making tear gas illegal during warfare, which does apply to tear gas and make perfect sense.

That's not the same thing as saying taxation is theft, or MLK is bad.

Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by gruez on Sunday March 16, 2025 @07:46PM (#43383725)
>Not really, no. The Geneva Convention has specific reasoning and rationale for making tear gas illegal during warfare, which does apply to tear gas and make perfect sense.

Mind elaborating? The arguments in sibling comments seem to be some variant of "avoid escalating to more dangerous chemical agents". I don't see how that's relevant to protests. Are we seriously expecting the protesters to escalate to mustard gas because the police used tear gas?

Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by mandmandam on Sunday March 16, 2025 @07:56PM (#43383780)
Even if mustard gas escalation is unlikely in protests, the reasoning behind banning the use of tear gas on protesters still matters:

1. The ban sends a clear message: chemical weapons of any kind are too dangerous to use on people. That's a good and important message to send.

2. If a government uses tear gas on its own citizens but condemns it in war, it creates a moral contradiction (even if the government don't see it that way).

3. Normalization - just as in war, allowing tear gas domestically could open the door to more severe measures over time. Maybe not mustard gas, but you know, that's not the only possible escalation.

4. When the government are describing peaceful protesters as "terrorists", and abducting them pending illegal deportation, arguing to give them carte blanche on using sonic and chemical weapons to suppress protest is... Well, it's kinda fascist. I don't know a nicer way to say it. Context matters.

Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by gruez on Sunday March 16, 2025 @08:04PM (#43383834)
>1. The ban sends a clear message: chemical weapons of any kind are too dangerous to use on people. That's a good and important message to send.

This is begging the question. The topic being discussed is whether "all chemical weapons (including tear gas) are bad". You can't use "we should ban all chemical weapons because it sends a clear message that all chemical weapons are bad" as a reason to justify that, it's circular reasoning.

> 2. If a government uses tear gas on its own citizens but condemns it in war, it creates a moral contradiction (even if the government don't see it that way).

It's only a moral contradiction when people fall for the non-central fallacy that all chemical weapons are bad. Pepper spray is technically a "chemical weapon", but the average person isn't going to think that someone using a pepper spray is somehow comparable to Germans flooding the front lines with mustard gas.

>3. Normalization - just as in war, allowing tear gas domestically could open the door to more severe measures over time.

You can literally say that about any other bad thing that police does. It's not specific to tear gas, or the geneva convention.

>4. When the government are describing peaceful protesters as "terrorists", and abducting them pending illegal deportation, arguing to give them carte blanche on using sonic and chemical weapons to suppress protest is... Well, it's kinda fucking fascist. I don't know a nicer way to say it.

This is obvious a derail, and has nothing to do with the use of tear gas.

Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by mandmandam on Monday March 17, 2025 @05:23AM (#43386549)
> This is begging the question.

It's not. It's about setting a clear legal line.

> It's only a moral contradiction when people fall for the non-central fallacy that all chemical weapons are bad.

Who's begging the question here?

> You can literally say that about any other bad thing that police does.

Maybe police shouldn't be doing bad things? ... And maybe supporting them when they do bad things is also bad?

> This is obvious a derail, and has nothing to do with the use of tear gas, or the geneva convention.

Fascists and chemical weapons are not separate questions, because fascists are known to use extreme measures when suppressing dissent; systematically escalating past all previous reasonable lines.

Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by gruez on Monday March 17, 2025 @09:45AM (#43388554)
>It's not. It's about setting a clear legal line.

Which one is it? Are you sticking to the exact wording of the law (ie. that all chemical weapons are banned), or the principle (that we shouldn't use substances like mustard gas against combatants)? If you're going to stick to the exact wording, you should also note that the geneva convention only applies to conflicts between countries, so chemicals weapon use by police forces don't contravene it. There's no "legal line" being broken.

>Who's begging the question here?

It really isn't, given that I have plenty of other objections that don't depend on using the non-central fallacy, and the comment you replied to doesn't even mention the non-central fallacy.

>Maybe police shouldn't be doing bad things? ... And maybe supporting them when they do bad things is also bad?

I'm not sure how you got the impression, given that I specifically said otherwise in my previous comment:

"But that's fine, because you can still object to those things even if they're not banned by the geneva convention."

>Fascists and chemical weapons are not separate questions, because fascists are known to use extreme measures when suppressing dissent; systematically escalating past all previous reasonable lines.

None of this has anything to do with the geneva convention or the use of tear gas. Moreover this presumes that if it wasn't for tear gas, police would stand down, when realistically speaking they'll just escalate to more lethal weapons.

Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by mandmandam on Monday March 17, 2025 @10:33AM (#43389017)
> this presumes that if it wasn't for tear gas, police would stand down, when realistically speaking they'll just escalate to more lethal weapons.

When cops use tear gas on peaceful protesters, a sizable segment of the population shrugs. That's nor the case when "more lethal weapons" are used.

Do you have stocks in tear gas manufacturers or something? This endless sea lioning is super weird. Every attempt to explain what the noncentral fallacy actually is and why it doesn't apply here just seems to leave you more confused, so I'mma stop trying. Good luck!

Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by beepbooptheory on Sunday March 16, 2025 @07:36PM (#43383667)
I believe you have misunderstood this (extremely dumb) article.

The idea and significance of the proper noun 'The Geneva Convention' is a much different class than just a noun like 'criminal' or 'murder'. The point of invoking it is not to hide behind an abstraction, but in fact to appeal to something specific.

Unless you just read that article as "how to be uncharitable," your point does not make any sense.

Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by gruez on Sunday March 16, 2025 @07:42PM (#43383706)
>The idea and significance of the proper noun 'The Geneva Convention' is a much different class than just a noun like 'criminal' or 'murder'. The point of invoking it is not to hide behind an abstraction, but in fact to appeal to something specific.

What is it appealing to then? When you say "violates the Geneva convention", I'm thinking of things like genocide, killing of civilians, and soldiers in trenches choking to death because they couldn't put their gas mask in time. None of that applies to tear gas.

Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by beepbooptheory on Sunday March 16, 2025 @08:29PM (#43383971)
Insofar as you want to continue to charge this fallacy here, it doesn't really matter because "the Geneva Convention" is not, per the cited article, a "category whose archetypal member gives us a certain emotional reaction." It is something specific that happened/exists, and in that it has no "archetypal member." Whether you specifically have an emotional reaction to it is beyond the point, and in fact beyond gp's point. If you take the argument minimally charitably its just pointing out an inconsistency between what was at once point judged to be bad by an international community, and the actions of one member of that community today.

But further, do you really, in good faith, think gp was trying to form some airtight logical argument against the use of tear gas? Do you think its possible they were maybe just pointing something interesting out? What actual motive could you have to try and create this very thin gotcha here? Can you maybe step back and see how sealioning like this just adds noise?

Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by gruez on Sunday March 16, 2025 @08:55PM (#43384110)
>Insofar as you want to continue to charge this fallacy here, it doesn't really matter because "the Geneva Convention" is not, per the cited article, a "category whose archetypal member gives us a certain emotional reaction." It is something specific that happened/exists, and in that it has no "archetypal member."

The exact phrasing used in the quoted post was "violate the Geneva convention". I don't know about you, but "violate the Geneva convention" does give me an emotional reaction.

>If you take the argument minimally charitably [...]

Like you're doing above by some clever rewording?

>its just pointing out an inconsistency between what was at once point judged to be bad by an international community, and the actions of one member of that community today.

I seriously doubt any member of "the international community" thinks that tear gas is somehow comparable to a war crime or using mustard gas, or that it's somehow extra bad because it's a chemical weapon. Moreover if you really want to cling onto what was written (ie. "no chemical weapons") vs what's intended (ie. "no mustard gas deployed in the trenches"), the geneva convention also has a specific carve-out for domestic use.

>BBut further, do you really, in good faith, think gp was trying to form some airtight logical argument against the use of tear gas? Do you think its possible they were maybe just pointing something interesting out? What actual motive could you have to try and create this very thin gotcha here?

Because I think it's interesting to point out how the non-central fallacy might apply here :^)

Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by fc417fc802 on Sunday March 16, 2025 @08:32PM (#43383981)
> this (extremely dumb) article

What's dumb about it? People often use labels in bad faith. I'd think that learning to recognize that is a good thing.

Of course the larger issue is that you are unlikely to be able to have a constructive dialogue with someone who is engaging in such tactics. Pointing out that someone is behaving poorly rarely solves the issue. I think it's still useful to be able to recognize the pattern though.