Re:I stopped everything and started writing C again
by int_19h on Saturday March 15, 2025 @02:46AM
(#43370534)
Well, we are comparing real world languages, so of course I'm going to talk about the limitations of the actual checker that Rust has. That said, is there a better (as in fewer false positives without giving up safety) implementation of lifetime tracking out there? I mean, fundamentally, the problem is that the question ultimately boils down to telling what the code will do without running it.
C and Zig have exactly the same facility to let you specify who's responsible for allocation - owning vs non-owning types for resources; it's just that you have to write them by hand, and for types that are owning, destructor calls must be done explicitly (but still, the pattern of "if I got an instance of OwnedFoo, I need to call destroy() on it" is much more straightforward then chasing the docs for each function).
C and Zig have exactly the same facility to let you specify who's responsible for allocation - owning vs non-owning types for resources; it's just that you have to write them by hand, and for types that are owning, destructor calls must be done explicitly (but still, the pattern of "if I got an instance of OwnedFoo, I need to call destroy() on it" is much more straightforward then chasing the docs for each function).