News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:DOGE's government cuts may hurt business, companies warn ... by xpe on Wednesday March 12, 2025 @11:18AM (#43344185)
A follow up idea: Don’t forget we modelers are still in a phase that might be characterized as “shifting mindsets”. The capability to model is getting steadily better, but I don’t think the practice of modeling is anywhere close to maturity nor broad diffusion.

I was hopeful ~5-10 years ago with the rise of data science, but I don’t know how much this growth corresponded with decision makers using the models both broadly and in intellectually honest ways.

There are areas where the results seem clear; e.g. advertising and product-specific decision points, such as recommendation engines.

Beyond these short-term ML applications, there are other domains where modeling is essential: weather forecasting, politics, markets, economics. But this is just the tip of the iceberg.

Here is a metric I’m interested in: what percentage of decisions are informed by quantitative models?

Aside: Before you complain that e.g. “some decisions aren’t impactful enough to warrant a model-backed approach”, let me say that I sort of agree, but… There are indeed lightweight quantitative models (or at least processes) that can track / predict when using a heavier model is worth it!

I don’t have systematic data on this; it is just a hunch, inspired by what I have heard and seen.

Why? Effective modeling provides differential advantages.

-intra-organizational diffusion: technically savvy people will rise into management.

- inter-organizational dispersion: techniques used by winners will spread across organizations and industries.

There are no comments on this comment yet.