I'm not looking for dogmatic assertions, I mean the fundamental and reproducible papers proving those claims.
Because those are all in direct opposition with the parent. And two views of an issue will not be resolved by each claiming opposite dogma.
Hopefully someone can present the evidence. A textbook citation is not enough. Are there really controlled experiments showing these things? Or is it mostly theoretical? Is it time to ask what we know--are these "facts we have been taught", or have we looked into the scientific validity of the proofs with the criticality of a practicing scientist?
I think that very solid citations here would actually go a long way to inform the parent, but I doubt that anything short of that would do so.
If, given all that, the difference between acceptance and rejection is some links in a forum post, there wasn't really any interest in the truth to start with.
Yes. And don't you use a /threshold/ mechanism to detect presence? Or you have tests so sensitive that a /single/ molecule or equivalent will deliver a reliably positive signal? I mean if it's that good why are you even doing PCR amplification in the first place?
> the standard is 30±10 cycles
The difference between 2^30 and 2^40 is massive.
The difference between a shitload and a bigger shitload reflects cycle count but not the nature of the result.
For diagnostic use like this, the standard is 30±10 cycles, but it doesn't really matter if it's ten or a hundred, since all you're really doing is verifying the presence of the target genome.