News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:AI is becoming 'yes-men on servers' by red75prime on Tuesday March 11, 2025 @03:30AM (#43330050)
> It's not something that can even have a real personality

What is a "real personality"? Core traits that persist despite the context of interaction?

Well, RLHF tuning creates persistent changes in the network that affect every user interaction. What's not real about it?

Re:AI is becoming 'yes-men on servers' by hatefulmoron on Tuesday March 11, 2025 @05:19AM (#43330652)
I'm curious, can you really not detect any qualitative difference between what is commonly understood to be "personality" in a human, and the "personality" of something without.. personhood? Don't you feel that it's a category error to say it has "personality" in the human sense, rather than "personality" in the car or coffee maker sense?
Re:AI is becoming 'yes-men on servers' by red75prime on Thursday March 13, 2025 @02:02PM (#43355789)
I feel that "category error" means "I think that the definitions you use or imply are wrong, but I can't/won't elaborate."

LLMs aren't coffee makers. They were trained on internet-worth of human data. They have procedures to imitate all kinds of personalities. RLHF moves the network towards a specific imitated personalty (a helpful assistant, usually).

The question in not "do they have it", but "how close the imitation to the real thing given the limitations of LLMs".

Re:AI is becoming 'yes-men on servers' by hatefulmoron on Saturday March 15, 2025 @12:17AM (#43369943)
> I feel that "category error" means "I think that the definitions you use or imply are wrong, but I can't/won't elaborate."

I think the rest of your comment motivates why I think it's a category error quite nicely. The word 'personality', for me, is connected with how things like emotion, temperament, .. impact a person's actions and thoughts.

Therefore, saying an object, or LLM, has 'real' personality is a category error. The LLM doesn't have any of those things. As you say, it imitates what personality often manifests as: word choices, tone, length of response..

To be clear, when I refer to things like 'emotion' and 'temperament', I mean the sort of qualia or qualitative experience that we usually attach to these words. I wouldn't accept a "ChatGPT, act as if you're sad for the rest of this conversation" as a substitute for emotion, for instance.