News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Jeep Owners Fed Up with In-Car Pop-Up Ads by kccqzy on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @04:33PM (#43272816)
That has little to do with advertising though. When you drive, you still see billboards with advertising. When you take public transit, the buses and the trains can have ads inside and outside.
Re:Jeep Owners Fed Up with In-Car Pop-Up Ads by cafard on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @04:51PM (#43273087)
Some states sharply restrict roadside advertising--Maryland does, Pennsylvania doesn't.

The bus advertising business seemed to have taken a beating a few years back. It is true that in Washington the bus shelters have ads, often electronic.

Re:Jeep Owners Fed Up with In-Car Pop-Up Ads by Marsymars on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @05:28PM (#43273583)
> When you drive, you still see billboards with advertising. When you take public transit, the buses and the trains can have ads inside and outside.

I regularly complain about both of those things to all of the relevant political and transit authorities.

Re:Jeep Owners Fed Up with In-Car Pop-Up Ads by ziddoap on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @04:45PM (#43272996)
This sort of misses the point, and treats all advertisement as equally annoying.

Advertisements inside my car, especially if the begin to use my speakers, is infinitely more annoying than a billboard (which, yes, is also annoying).

Advertisements on trains/etc. are more annoying than billboards, but less annoying than advertisements in something I am supposed to own.

Re:Jeep Owners Fed Up with In-Car Pop-Up Ads by ben_w on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @04:50PM (#43273064)
> When you drive, you still see billboards with advertising.

Far more so in the US[0] than in any of the parts of Europe I've lived in or visited[1].

[0] Around much of CA, RI, MA, passing through NV and CT, and the cities of NYC, Salt Lake City and Newark in NY, UT and NJ.

[1] Spain, France, UK, Belgium, Luxembourg, Netherlands, Switzerland, Sweden, Germany, Italy, Austria, Poland, Hungry, Finland, Greece, Cyprus.

Re:Jeep Owners Fed Up with In-Car Pop-Up Ads by spudlyo on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @04:55PM (#43273150)
Whenever AR glasses with ad-blockers are available, I will be an early adopter.
Re:Jeep Owners Fed Up with In-Car Pop-Up Ads by codebje on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @06:33PM (#43274273)
Bold assumption that AR glasses won’t just be a way to deliver more targeted advertising.
Re:Jeep Owners Fed Up with In-Car Pop-Up Ads by nickthegreek on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @07:16PM (#43274572)
In the free market of the future, I’m sure we will have both. It’s just the poor that will need to have their visions modified in their manicured adscapes of despair fashion specs. Also, the poor will be a larger share of the population.
Re:Jeep Owners Fed Up with In-Car Pop-Up Ads by INGSOCIALITE on Thursday March 06, 2025 @11:13PM (#43287339)
there's probably a huge market for novelty AI glasses that just show messaging from "they live" superimposed over all billboards
Re:Jeep Owners Fed Up with In-Car Pop-Up Ads by exe34 on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @04:40PM (#43272928)
I took the bus from the airport into Istanbul, and it had a horribly bright screen in front of every seat, with flashing adverts and constantly moving - after a flight, I was already feeling nauseous. I managed to cover it with a jacket and ignore the ones further away, but it was a very unpleasant experience.
Re:Jeep Owners Fed Up with In-Car Pop-Up Ads by Marsymars on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @05:29PM (#43273608)
I’d consider a socially positive action to render those screens inoperable.
Re:Jeep Owners Fed Up with In-Car Pop-Up Ads by exe34 on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @05:36PM (#43273691)
as a foreigner who didn't speak the local language, I didn't think vandalism was a good idea.
Re:Jeep Owners Fed Up with In-Car Pop-Up Ads by Marsymars on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @05:43PM (#43273767)
Yes, ideally they could be disabled by some enterprising local youths who are too young to face consequences.
Re:Jeep Owners Fed Up with In-Car Pop-Up Ads by striking on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @04:44PM (#43272984)
Yeah, but at least buses and trains are accountable to the voter in one way or another... and I can still wear headphones.
Re:Jeep Owners Fed Up with In-Car Pop-Up Ads by gruez on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @04:48PM (#43273042)
You can vote with your wallet and buy a car that doesn't have ads. The best you can do with ads on buses and trains is show up in your next city council meeting and raise a stink, only to be told that the transit agency signed a 10 year contract and can't pull out.
Re:Jeep Owners Fed Up with In-Car Pop-Up Ads by ziddoap on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @04:52PM (#43273110)
This assumes that no other manufacturer will put ads in their cars. Hopefully that's the case!

I think the concern is that once/if a critical mass of manufacturers include in-car ads, the rest can follow (because people still need vehicles in most areas), and the consumer has no more choice.

Re:Jeep Owners Fed Up with In-Car Pop-Up Ads by gruez on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @05:02PM (#43273250)
Is there any reason to believe they won't have a higher ad-free tier instead? If they get $500 LTV from showing ads, why wouldn't they offer a $1000 ad-free subscription? Seems to work fine with streaming platforms, for instance.
Re:Jeep Owners Fed Up with In-Car Pop-Up Ads by ziddoap on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @05:03PM (#43273274)
>Is there any reason to believe they won't have a higher ad-free tier instead?

I mean, this is still awful, right? Subscriptions for the car I spent tens of thousands of dollars on?

>Seems to work fine with streaming platforms, for instance.

It's awful here, too, in my opinion. But tolerable because I didn't spend multiple years paying to own the product.

Re:Jeep Owners Fed Up with In-Car Pop-Up Ads by gruez on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @07:36PM (#43274694)
>I mean, this is still awful, right? Subscriptions for the car I spent tens of thousands of dollars on?

Alternatively framed: $1000/year discount for opting into ads.

Re:Jeep Owners Fed Up with In-Car Pop-Up Ads by ziddoap on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @08:24PM (#43275105)
The difference being that my previous car lasted near 15 years, and it was paid off in 7. Why would you want to pay a yearly fee after you're supposed to own the car, free and clear?

I'll save us the back and forth: there is no model you can present (or reframing of a model) that will make me think advertisements (or an everlasting subscription to remove advertisements) in the car that I own is okay. It's profoundly depressing that I have to write it out that explicitly.

Re:Jeep Owners Fed Up with In-Car Pop-Up Ads by alistairSH on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @05:26PM (#43273558)
Did the owners know they would be served ads when they purchased the car? That’s not clear to me.
Re:Jeep Owners Fed Up with In-Car Pop-Up Ads by gruez on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @07:33PM (#43274669)
Unless you go to every transit board meeting, you probably won't know that your local bus is going to have digital ad displays plastered on them either. Even then, such issues rarely come up as a ballot initiative so the most you can do is make an impassioned speech and hope they reverse course. So both cases are pretty similar, actually. You're choosing something (car brand/politician), vaguely hoping they serve your interests, and hope that the threat if you switching to competitors is enough to keep them in line.
Re:Jeep Owners Fed Up with In-Car Pop-Up Ads by alistairSH on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @08:35PM (#43275207)
Uh, buses have had ads on the sides forever, at least in the US.

Buying a car, which haven’t had ads previously, only to discover after the fact that it serves ads is a change to the status quo. Even more so if the ads were pushed via firmware update and not something that was originally spec’ed (no clue if this is what happened, but sounds plausible, given lack of details).

Re:Jeep Owners Fed Up with In-Car Pop-Up Ads by gruez on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @08:48PM (#43275306)
>Uh, buses have had ads on the sides forever, at least in the US.

That's why I mentioned "digital ad displays" specifically, because as other commenters have noted, are starting to pop up in some places.

Re:Jeep Owners Fed Up with In-Car Pop-Up Ads by davidcbc on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @04:54PM (#43273143)
> You can vote with your wallet and buy a car that doesn't have ads.

For now.

I've yet to see an advertisement on a bus or train that wasn't easily ignorable. It's a lot harder to ignore things when you're driving

Re:Jeep Owners Fed Up with In-Car Pop-Up Ads by ale42 on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @04:39PM (#43272905)
Yes but you don't own the bus/train nor the road with the billboards. But supposedly, you do own the car. Do cars get cheaper by adding ads inside? Nope.
Re:Jeep Owners Fed Up with In-Car Pop-Up Ads by gruez on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @04:51PM (#43273084)
>Yes but you don't own the bus/train nor the road with the billboards. But supposedly, you do own the car

As opposed to a TV that you own? You even paid for the cable subscription.