Re:Dear Mark Zuckerberg
by caleywoods on Wednesday August 01, 2012 @04:34PM
(#4325512)
Wrong. He's angry because he didn't want to be acquired and didn't want to have his business shut down by Facebook turning off his access.
Nothing in the post suggests that Facebook threatened to turn off access.
They threatened this in a phone call, but he didn't record it so he didn't include it in the letter: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4325593
No, he didn't want to be acquired, and he didn't want to go to an aggressive acquisition negotiation meeting, since there would be no terms he would accept. He only went to the meeting because he thought it was a demo.
Edit: actually, we're both right, according to the alleged contents of a phone call http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4325586
They spent a lot of time working on a product and then had the choice of either giving it to Facebook (selling) or writing off the entire effort.
From a business standpoint, that's just the way our society works.
The problem is the concept of business and how it controls all aspects of our lives and opposes technological progress.
I agree 100% on the first point, I feel like open letters on HN are mostly a pity-party due to someones bad experience with a/b company.
Also other developers need to realize that Facebooks moves in this meeting are business as usual.
Put yourselves in their shoes and realize what their motives are as a company.
This person is complaining because he didn't want to be acquired by Facebook but would like them to not compete with him. Oh well.