News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:"Students Today Are Completely Full of Shit." by yan on Tuesday January 13, 2009 @02:30PM (#432544)
I love reading posts like this. Something about hearing the non-PC version of ideas make me smile inside. Same was with the Kindergarchy article (http://www.weeklystandard.com/Content/Public/Articles/000/00...). Same with people who argue that those that are successful aren't just successful because they're solely "lucky", but actually put in the hard work. Ditto for Elizer's post on Overcoming Bias that claimed that the successful actually are more talented, gifted and intelligent than "average" people. Even if its distorted more towards pessimism than the usual "feel-good" posts on success, I would still believe it more.

I just don't understand why there is almost no pessimism in main-stream media. I guess it doesn't scale.

Re:"Students Today Are Completely Full of Shit." by m0nty on Tuesday January 13, 2009 @02:50PM (#432576)
> I just don't understand why there is almost no pessimism in main-stream media.

Read any articles about the economy recently? Plenty of pessimism. Now, if you're talking about cynicism - I love cynicism, at least when it's done well. Most people think being cynical means being petty-minded and always running down other people's motives and achievements. Far from it: a good cynic is someone who genuinely loves genuine achievement, but is prepared to articulately, pugnaciously and mercilessly draw attention to those who fall short. Good cynics are basically weary optimists.

Re:"Students Today Are Completely Full of Shit." by astine on Tuesday January 13, 2009 @03:16PM (#432614)
"I'm not a cynic, I just have high standards."
Re:"Students Today Are Completely Full of Shit." by electromagnetic on Tuesday January 13, 2009 @03:53PM (#432684)
I believe one of the main things that encouraged me into writing was because of people saying, "writing is hard work." It's mostly hard work because there's a 100 distractions to take you over and, I imagine coding is the same, it takes a lot of commitment to focus on working when it's quite simple to just do nothing.
Re:"Students Today Are Completely Full of Shit." by anthonyrubin on Tuesday January 13, 2009 @02:41PM (#432562)
Re:"Students Today Are Completely Full of Shit." by Gibbon on Tuesday January 13, 2009 @03:07PM (#432597)
You don't need to pay to watch the whole movie.. it's available on google video: http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=-856606244008931882&...

It's a great little movie. Taken out of context the quote is a tad pessimistic, but the movie is actually quite uplifting.

Re:"Students Today Are Completely Full of Shit." by pxlpshr on Tuesday January 13, 2009 @04:29PM (#432732)
The movie is great and was filmed in ~2005, released in 2006 I believe.

http://beforethemusicdies.com

Re:"Students Today Are Completely Full of Shit." by bprater on Tuesday January 13, 2009 @02:49PM (#432572)
If we go through another great depression, perhaps a new generation that has true grit will have better clarity and perspective on what it takes to succeed.
Re:"Students Today Are Completely Full of Shit." by yan on Tuesday January 13, 2009 @03:13PM (#432609)
.. until the next bubble/depression.
Re:"Students Today Are Completely Full of Shit." by TomOfTTB on Tuesday January 13, 2009 @03:23PM (#432625)
I think this is just a cycle the world has to go through. You have a society right now that feels entitled and thinks very highly of themselves despite having done very little. These people go around acting on those assumptions and basically crash and burn (For example, all those people who thought they deserved houses they couldn’t pay for and now have no house at all)

Then their kids have to work a lot harder to succeed because their parents are (a) too narcissistic to provide emotional support and (b) too poor after they’ve crashed and burned to provide financial support. So the generation of people who thought too highly of themselves and did very little work spawns a generation of hard working, motivated people.

Sadly, what tends to happen after is that the hard working generation lavishes their kids with praise and financial support to make up for all the things they didn’t have as a kid which creates another generation of spoiled kids. But what can you do.

Re:"Students Today Are Completely Full of Shit." by tkiley on Tuesday January 13, 2009 @02:56PM (#432584)
The Youtube clip is from an interview with Branford Marsalis in the documentary film "Before The Music Dies". The whole thing is definitely worth seeing, if you have any interest in music or business. It's available for $3 as an indie download.

http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0760307/ http://www.beforethemusicdies.com/blog/b4md

Re:"Students Today Are Completely Full of Shit." by pstinnett on Tuesday January 13, 2009 @02:44PM (#432566)
Millennials were brought up with so much praise early on that I think this is hard to avoid. For example, when learning how to spell a student could spell something totally incorrect but they would still receive a "gold star" because they tried and guessed the number of correct letters in the word. Yes, a lot of students don't want to work hard. Is it 100% their fault or should some responsibility fall on this over-praise from teachers?
Re:"Students Today Are Completely Full of Shit." by Chocobean on Tuesday January 13, 2009 @03:06PM (#432594)
it's true: 100% of children from north american middle-income families are gifted. They go to schools where the teachers are not allowed to mark their work with a red pen, not allowed to draw an X or circle an incorrect answer, and not allowed to call a wrong answer a wrong answer -- it's a "good try."

I dont think the teachers are to blame, tho, they're also stuck in the system. You think they dont' want to grab an arrogant "gifted kid" by the shoulders and shake him, or to tear up poorly written essays in front of the whole class? The good old days....

Re:"Students Today Are Completely Full of Shit." by dhimes on Tuesday January 13, 2009 @03:38PM (#432652)
I don't know which schools you are talking about. The public schools my kids have been in mark plenty of things wrong, pull kids out of courses that they can't handle and put them in lower-level courses in the middle of a term, and fail kids who don't perform to a minimum standard.
Re:"Students Today Are Completely Full of Shit." by pstinnett on Tuesday January 13, 2009 @03:52PM (#432682)
I'm sure this is the case in some areas, but the No Child Left Behind act has a lot of administrators putting pressure on teachers to keep kids from failing, teaching to the minimum standard tests, etc.
Re:"Students Today Are Completely Full of Shit." by dhimes on Tuesday January 13, 2009 @04:52PM (#432773)
I've heard comments like this, but I can't say I've witnessed it. The pressure used to be on keeping kids from failing because the parents would complain. The school principals by and large took the sides of the parents. Without an outside measure of standards, teachers would pass the kids to get keep them off of their backs. Shame on them, but their pressures were real and unpleasant. At least, those were the complaints I heard from the teachers I knew (and who occasionally opined in more public fora).

When Virginia introduced the Standards of Learning tests (years before NCLB), an amazing thing happened: Teachers were still griping, but they were griping about how they were going to teach all of the stuff they now had to teach. Importantly, their conversations turned back to teaching.

Yes, there is pressure to keep kids from failing. But they simply can't be given a "social promotion" now; they are going to take an exam and will be exposed.

The teachers in the districts where I've been personally involved (via my kids) did something I think was pretty smart: they started getting the parents to sign progress reports and notices nearly continuously throughout the term. In some cases, the parents had to sign off on the assignments as they were give! So there are few surprises at the end of the term. Kind of a CYA move, but with all of the pressures (as you correctly pointed out) they had to do something.

The standards to which they are teaching aren't minimum at all. They are pretty high. My issue with them is that they are not well defined. But I'll save that for another post.

I'll conclude this post with the observation that what teachers are complaining about now is not teaching to the minimum standard tests, but rather that they have to teach to the test at all. They don't agree that what is important is being tested because it's hard to quantify. I have some sympathy for that point of view.

Re:"Students Today Are Completely Full of Shit." by Jebdm on Tuesday January 13, 2009 @03:55PM (#432687)
Maybe I just got lucky, but I'm a millenial and I never experienced any of this stuff. I agree that more students are considered gifted than ought to be, but I also think that the whole three-tier gifted/normal/special ed thing is broken. It's a spectrum, so treat it that way.

That said, I've never gotten a gold star that I can remember, and I've definitely received my fair share of red X's.

I did get stamps/stickers on papers which were A's or, in the lower grades, check-pluses or E's. But I don't think that these in any way gave me a false sense of accomplishment; they only gave them out for top marks. (For the uninitiated, sometimes for minor assignments we were graded on a scale that went v+, v, v-, X or Excellent, Good, Satisfactory, Poor.)

Maybe this is a big issue in other places, or perhaps private schools (that seems likely to me, based on the accounts of some people I know who attended private school), but it's definitely not happening everywhere.

Re:"Students Today Are Completely Full of Shit." by pstinnett on Tuesday January 13, 2009 @03:14PM (#432611)
Agreed. I just think the problem is bigger than "Students are full of shit".
Re:"Students Today Are Completely Full of Shit." by dhimes on Tuesday January 13, 2009 @03:35PM (#432648)
I thought it was weird too, until I had kids in school. Then I saw the the kids were writing stories in Kindergarten, a good three years earlier than before. It seems that the part of the brain that can handle stories and cause/effect develops earlier than the part that handles details (like spelling).

Instead of waiting until they were old enough to spell correctly, they started letting them do what they could do earlier.

They do the same thing with physical fitness. To achieve the presidential award, you don't have to be as strong or as fast in third grade as you do in sixth.

Re:"Students Today Are Completely Full of Shit." by stcredzero on Tuesday January 13, 2009 @03:42PM (#432661)
I think I know how this came about. You can't teach something at all complex by constantly telling them "nope, that's not it." If you keep on doing that, you just shut them down. Positive reinforcement is the most effective way. The key is to set appropriate goals and rewards. Rewarding a kid for butchering a word spelling is not productive. Rewarding a kid for getting the spelling wrong, but successfully applying, "I before E except after C, or pronounced A as in neighbor or weigh" is worthwhile.
Re:"Students Today Are Completely Full of Shit." by nihilocrat on Tuesday January 13, 2009 @03:38PM (#432653)
"That is what I’ve learned from my students. Much like the generation before them, the only thing they are really interested in is you telling them how right they are and how good they are."

Emphasis is mine. I think we've seen this before. Snore.

Re:"Students Today Are Completely Full of Shit." by jgilliam on Tuesday January 13, 2009 @03:19PM (#432619)
Seems like there would be a market for colleges that make it very difficult to get good grades because those degrees/grades would then be more prestigious.
Re:"Students Today Are Completely Full of Shit." by ruddzw on Tuesday January 13, 2009 @03:40PM (#432658)
Here at Cornell, the general consensus among students is that it's really hard to get good grades, especially among some majors. Cornell started a few years ago releasing "Median Grade Reports" so that students would see what classes were easy and hard in terms of grading. The idea was that students would enroll in classes with low median grades so that they could challenge themselves. Instead, people took the reports and took as many classes as they could with high median grades, so they would have an easier time and a higher GPA.

Sure, people come here because it's known to be hard. But once they're here that goes out the window. You're trying for grades, not challenges.

Re:"Students Today Are Completely Full of Shit." by RK on Tuesday January 13, 2009 @04:35PM (#432748)
When I was an undergrad, organic chemistry was widely considered to be the hardest. They eventually released some grade statistics like the ones you mentioned and it showed that organic chemistry had the highest mean grade and the highest percentage of A+'s of any course.

Of course it was full of pre-meds and chemical engineering majors (ie. pre-oil). Draw your own conclusions.

The departments that had the lowest mean grades across their courses were physics and economics. I took that to mean that physics was actually a very difficult major (I admit I'm biased here). Economics, on the other hand, was what most of the scholarship athletes majored in (my university didn't offer communications or marketing degrees that you sometimes see). Not to say that economics wasn't difficult, though I never had a chance to take any courses.

Re:"Students Today Are Completely Full of Shit." by icefox on Tuesday January 13, 2009 @04:20PM (#432714)
Why would you go for challenges, your first job isn't going to ask you for how challenging your classes were, but for your grades. Higher grades == more pay.
Re:"Students Today Are Completely Full of Shit." by potatolicious on Tuesday January 13, 2009 @04:27PM (#432725)
Not to mention many people intend to go to grad school - where grades are king, and nobody really cares if your marks are low because you were challenging yourself.

The system shares as much blame as its users. If challenging oneself was rewarded then we'd have more of it.

Re:"Students Today Are Completely Full of Shit." by jmatt on Tuesday January 13, 2009 @04:20PM (#432713)
Try most state schools. For example someone with an A+ at University of Illinois is going to be 1 in a few hundred. They were the very top in that class, and most of the classes are large. Even people with A's are likely to be top 10-15%. And there may be no one with A's. Heck, it's likely some people completely failed even when they were trying. Why? Every professor grades how they see fit. Yes, this is department and degree specific. If a department wants to make their degree tough then they do. If too many people are applying - raise the bar until you end up with only the best.

It's the difference between an elite education and the rest of us educated people^. Now, this doesn't apply to all the big name schools. I think there is a market for schools that make it tough. Look at which schools hackers think are the best in science/math/enginnering schools CalTech, MIT, Stanford, CMU, etc. They are still tough with less grade inflation. (I apologize if I left your favorite top school out of the list, assume I included it)

^I may not agree entirely but it's an interesting read: http://www.theamericanscholar.org/the-disadvantages-of-an-el...

Re:"Students Today Are Completely Full of Shit." by msie on Tuesday January 13, 2009 @03:10PM (#432603)
I don't think all students are completely full of shit. I believe the distribution is a bell curve. ;)
Re:"Students Today Are Completely Full of Shit." by xenophanes on Tuesday January 13, 2009 @03:17PM (#432615)
Each of his students is now thinking to himself, "Wow, I didn't realize I was his best student."
Re:"Students Today Are Completely Full of Shit." by peregrine on Tuesday January 13, 2009 @03:32PM (#432640)
Right, there are no smart hard working kids anymore just bastards? WRONG. There are the same number of smart kids, just many many more students in college who probably don't belong anyways and will eventually fail.

Sounds like a bunch of bs to me.

Re:"Students Today Are Completely Full of Shit." by run4yourlives on Tuesday January 13, 2009 @03:30PM (#432637)
Quote of the day:

We live in a country that seems to be in this massive state of delusion, where the idea of what you are is more important than you actually being that.

Re:"Students Today Are Completely Full of Shit." by fabjan on Tuesday January 13, 2009 @03:44PM (#432664)
Well... This is kind of bound to happen if you let the market rule your educational system.
Re:"Students Today Are Completely Full of Shit." by ii on Tuesday January 13, 2009 @04:25PM (#432721)
Because those who are not are self-taught ;) Credentials are losing their power.
Re:"Students Today Are Completely Full of Shit." by edw519 on Tuesday January 13, 2009 @02:52PM (#432579)
Wow. What an indictment from someone in a position of respect. I'm not sure exactly what he's talking about. A few examples would have helped. On second thought, I'm not sure I wanna know.

OTOH, maybe this is an great opportunity for him to be the first good teacher many of these students ever had.