News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why I Hate Frameworks by thomasmallen on Tuesday January 13, 2009 @12:22PM (#432287)
No, that mistake typically is a result of somebody faulting Ruby for Rails' problems. As the parent to my comment said,

Rails: Here's a kick-ass hammer, a kick-ass saw, a kick-ass measure tape, etc...

My point is that those kick-ass tools may be made of balsa. The editorial that I linked immediately came to mind because it too used tools as an analogy.

Re:Why I Hate Frameworks by dasil003 on Tuesday January 13, 2009 @03:52PM (#432683)
I'm starting to see why a lot of people say all software development analogies suck. What does it mean to say its tools would break under duress, or they're made of balsa wood? You can interpret those analogies any way you want.

The bottom line is the Ruby runtime has some serious flaws, but they are not so pervasive as to make everything in Ruby total crap. There's a good chance you could write an application in half the time it would take in Java and experience no problems ever. It's also possible you'll hit a memory leak and have to face an ugly workaround, partial rewrite or even scrap the whole Ruby project. Finally, you may have a memory leak and find an easy workaround, and then one day the problem is magically solved by Rubinius.

Those are concrete scenarios to consider. I don't see how a physical materials analogy has any value in analyzing your options. The pros and cons of languages don't align AT ALL with physical properties. Thoughts like, "Java is more like cast iron, and Python is more like hardwood" is just one-dimensional mental masturbation. In the end the reason to choose a language like Java because you are willing to tolerate more overhead for less risk.

Re:Why I Hate Frameworks by swombat on Tuesday January 13, 2009 @12:33PM (#432305)
Re:Why I Hate Frameworks by thomasmallen on Tuesday January 13, 2009 @12:40PM (#432317)
About?
Re:Why I Hate Frameworks by swombat on Tuesday January 13, 2009 @12:43PM (#432323)
Suggesting that rails is a kick-ass tool made of balsa.
Re:Why I Hate Frameworks by thomasmallen on Tuesday January 13, 2009 @12:47PM (#432334)
Not "is a," but rather, "may be." This is because I never personally experienced the problems noted in the link I posted, but they are coming from what appears to be a credible source. You mistook a suggestion of problems for a personal conviction.
Re:Why I Hate Frameworks by Nwallins on Tuesday January 13, 2009 @03:12PM (#432607)
> If Rails were a toolbox, all of its tools would break under duress.

That sure sounds like personal conviction to me.