News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A Letter to the American People by tac19 on Saturday March 01, 2025 @06:35PM (#43225264)
We've been told for a long time that the USA is a racist, sexist, illegitimate nation, founded on slavery and stolen land. Why are so many people, who believe these things, crying about America being delegitimized? Surely, its destruction at the hands of Donald Trump is a triumph of restorative justice.

In any case, you can't keep telling everyone the country is evil, and expect it to not have destructive consequences. It seems that part of what underlies support for Trump, is a rejection of that narrative, and on the flip side, also those who support that narrative to an extreme degree of wanting utter destruction of the system.

Re:A Letter to the American People by steego on Saturday March 01, 2025 @07:43PM (#43225858)
I didn’t grow up hearing that the U.S. was inherently evil.

I learned the messy, unfiltered history of an imperfect country—one built on a Constitution that has kept it going and evolving for nearly 250 years.

That same Constitution, which originally allowed slavery, also provided the legal framework to end it and later secure civil rights. In the early 20th century, it was amended to guarantee women the right to vote.

I was never taught that the U.S. was always a just and noble nation, nor that the founders were infallible. But I also wasn’t taught that the country was irredeemable.

Our best feature has always been our willingness to redeem ourselves by continually remaking ourselves rather tethering ourselves to our past wrongs. The fact that our constitution has multiple provisions for doing exactly this has always been its most impressive feature.

A society that can’t learn and accept the good and the bad of its history is a society doomed to stagnation -- morally, intellectually, and economically.

Re:A Letter to the American People by wesselbindt on Saturday March 01, 2025 @06:57PM (#43225497)
> Why are so many people, who believe these things, crying about America being delegitimized?

Well for me personally it's because of empathy. The United States, as you rightly point out, was founded on slavery and genocide. I agree with you, and I would also add that the US is responsible for the deaths of millions globally in the past century (let's take Iraq and Vietnam, and I think you're already over a million). Generally a force for evil.

But a nation's citizens are not responsible for the actions of its government. They do not deserve to lose their homes in forest fires, have their children attend school hungry, go bankrupt on account of having cancer, be steeped in lifelong debt just to afford an education, lose their child in a school shooting, et cetera. What Elon Musk is doing will make those things much worse. That's why people are upset.

Re:A Letter to the American People by tac19 on Saturday March 01, 2025 @07:03PM (#43225537)
There is a certain subset of people, who think no punishment is too great for the sins of the USA, and that all its civilians are enjoying unearned privilege -- and deserve to be humbled for their willingness to profit from such an evil system.

These are the same sort of people who fly planes into the twin towers in New York to kill civilians, (i'm not making any claim about this being restricted to any ethnicity or religion, just showing that such people do exist)

Re:A Letter to the American People by wesselbindt on Saturday March 01, 2025 @07:04PM (#43225552)
Your point being? You asked why people are upset about the gutting of public services. I gave you a reason why. This thing about 9/11 is a bit of a non sequitur.
Re:A Letter to the American People by tac19 on Saturday March 01, 2025 @07:12PM (#43225630)
My point is that your wonderful level of compassion and empathy wasn't heard by the people who voted for Trump. They only heard the first part of the message, of their complicity in evil, and culpability in profiting from the suffering inflicted by evil.

What i'm trying to argue for, is a softening of future messaging, that includes your warmth.

Re:A Letter to the American People by wesselbindt on Sunday March 02, 2025 @03:19AM (#43228464)
Right because what defeated fascism in WWII was our politeness. You're being silly.
Re:A Letter to the American People by tac19 on Sunday March 02, 2025 @12:45PM (#43232933)
You're missing the point. You didn't defeat fascism, you helped get it elected.
Re:A Letter to the American People by wesselbindt on Sunday March 02, 2025 @01:43PM (#43233559)
I'm not missing your point, I'm disagreeing with it.