Re:Stuff Harvard, MIT, Stanford & Caltech People Like
by ScottBurson on Wednesday August 01, 2012 @02:50AM
(#4321516)
Interesting. Would also like to see p(topic|school=X).
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Stuff Harvard, MIT, Stanford & Caltech People Like
by ballooney on Wednesday August 01, 2012 @03:15AM
(#4321581)
Well, god gave us Bayes' rule for a reason.
The article does not point out that sampling quora users might not be (I would say is probably not) an unbiased estimator of the the students of these places as a whole. Quora attracts a certain kind of person, I've never seen it mentioned anywhere outside of techy startup / valley circles. Maybe that's implied by virtue of it being in the HN ecosystem, but still it should be explicitly stated as a flaw in the method. Lies, damned lies and statistics etc.
Re:Stuff Harvard, MIT, Stanford & Caltech People Like
by azylman on Wednesday August 01, 2012 @03:29AM
(#4321608)
The article does not point out that sampling quora users might not be (I would say is probably not) an unbiased estimator of the the students of these places as a whole.
From the article:
Also, a word of warning: my dataset was fairly small and users on Quora are almost certainly not representative of their schools as a whole (though I tried to be rigorous with what I had).
Re:Stuff Harvard, MIT, Stanford & Caltech People Like
by ballooney on Wednesday August 01, 2012 @03:38AM
(#4321624)
I completely missed that, mea culpa, my apologies to the author. I'll leave the message above unedited as a little warning sign to other people who can't read: you too can look silly like me.
Re:Stuff Harvard, MIT, Stanford & Caltech People Like
by ScottBurson on Wednesday August 01, 2012 @12:50PM
(#4324031)
> Well, god gave us Bayes' rule for a reason.
She did. But She did not give us P(topic) and P(school) for this dataset.